@Setanta,
Setanta wrote:EDIT: I'm an atheist becaue i don't believe, not because i have a belief i want to proselytize. Campaigns like this are odious to me, and i suspect, tend to confirm the faulty perception many people have of atheists as just a different type of believer, willing to shove their "beliefs" down other people's throats.
Even if I tentatively accept, for the sake of discussion, that you don't have a belief and don't want to proselytize it, I disagree with your conclusion: This faulty perception about atheists predates the so-called
New Atheists, their notoriety, and the campaigns they inspired. In particular, FOX's propaganda about the alleged "war on Christmas" had been around for years when vocal atheists started speaking up about Newton Day. I don't see how vocal atheists
could make this any worse. They may as well get themselves pilloried for campaigns they actually do wage. Hung for a lamb, hung for a sheep.
Now, about this business of believing and proselytizing. Call it a strongly-held opinion, call it a belief, call it what you want. But I submit to you that you hold a strong,
affirmative conviction that consists of two points:
- Evidence and logic are good reasons to believe something.
- Nothing else is a good reason to believe anything. In particular, authority, tradition, revelation, and intuition are bad reasons to believe anything in the absence of evidence and logic.
Moreover, in addition to
holding this conviction, you
proselytize for it by routinely naming and shaming correspondents who, in your judgment, use shaky logic and dubious factoids. (I have been among those correspondents often enough to know.) Again, there are many other words we could use instead of "proselytize", but it does work just as well here.
Granted, your disbelief in god isn't the starting point of your belief, just its inevitable consequence. And perhaps I just misunderstand you as suggesting there's no affirmative belief involved on your part. But if that's indeed what you're saying, I think you're fooling yourself.