@panzade,
To finish the story, Pan and Osso. We are ready to roll across the street on the 6-story building (The Roof) and are starting the process across the street where a 9-story hotel might go (SycHouse).
We go before the BAR to ask for a demolition permit for the 2-story SycHouse building put up in 1945. Is it architecturally significant? I don't think so, unlike the buildings opposite the train station a few blocks away.
We broached this subject with the BAR a year ago and my architect was wary about asking for a vote. One member waxed poetic about the hardware store that was once there, and how he spent many a Saturday morning in the place. A couple of others favored facade-ism. Keep the street facing facade Main St but tear down whatever is behind it. Other members derided that as Disneyesque. We backed off.
The board now consists of different members. I think we are okay, but there will be some folks leaving to be replaced but we don't know by whom.