parados wrote:okie wrote:Nice try, Parados, but if you have classified information derived from x + y, it doesn't seem too bright to go around publishing what x is, does it?
Preposterous argument since there is no x+ y creating classified information. there is X and there is Y.
We are talking about connecting the dots, and the actual example is Novak, showing that it is not a preposterous argument at all, because it happened. He didn't have all the dots, so he simply went to Whos Who, and got the remainder of the dots, and connected them. I never claimed the Whos Who information outed Plame all by itself, however it helped facilitate the outing, as revealed to and written about by Novak.
It is totally illogical in my opinion for covert agents to have any information published about them in ways such as this. And this example proves it.
Whos Who is not the only place Wilson disclosed his wife's identity. Okay, so he did not say she was a covert agent, but
intelligence agencies around the world are not stupid. Any information surrounding a guy that is running off his mouth about WMD for the CIA is probably going to be run through the computers of intelligence agencies around the world, and that would include anything and everything that is connected with him, surely including his wife. After all, they only need to refer to Whos Who to find her name. Novak is not the only person capable of connecting dots. He did it without a computer.