@okie,
Let's take note that you have made two false statements: that Obama claimed that Sasha had meningitis, and that Michelle Obama stated that she didn't.
Look, this is really the problem I have with your style of accusing the Obamas: you throw out wild accusations, make wild claims about supposed contradictory statements, and when faced with the
actual quotes of what has been said, you don't even find it necessary to acknowledge that what has been said wasn't entirely what you claimed has been said.
Now, on the topic of meningit
is:
okie wrote:I realize also that a diagnosis could be wrong if it is premature, but typically a doctor will conduct tests that are conclusive before he will give what is known as a diagnosis.
As far as I know, the problem with meningitis is that, while it is a dangerous, potentially lethal disease, the symptoms can be quite ambiguous, particularly in small children. It requires immediate attention, and yet the only way to give a conclusive diagnosis is to perform a spinal tap.
In regard to Sasha's case: maybe treatment was started based on a preliminary diagnosis while the hospital was waiting for the test results. I don't know what happened, and neither do you. Not that that wouldn't stop you from throwing around accusations based on nothing but a few sound bites that you didn't even cite correctly.
okie wrote:In the case of Obama's daughter, the tests had not been run, but when they were, it apparently showed she did not have meningitus.
Yes, that's what the New York Times wrote. I have no reason to doubt the veracity of their article, but it doesn't necessarily contradict the Obama's
actual statement.
okie wrote:There is no evidence that a diagnosis of meningitus was ever given.
And there is no evidence that a diagnosis of meningitis
wasn't given at any point. Look, you're the one making these accusations. If you acknowledge that we can't possibly know whether or not a preliminary, possibly false diagnosis was given and whether or not treatment was or wasn't started based on that, I'll completely agree with you.
However, if you want to claim that at no point in time Sasha was even preliminarily diagnosed with meningitis, then you better back that up with some evidence.
okie wrote:As I understand it, the doctor never made that diagnosis, never.
Based on what evidence?
okie wrote:This is really a very simple matter of Obama making a false statement.
No, this is a simply matter of you making accusations without presenting any kind of evidence to back up those accusations.
So far you have claimed that
- Obama said that Sasha had meningitis (when he actually said that she was diagnosed with meningitis)
- Michelle Obama stated that it wasn't meningitis (when it was actually the NYT who made that statement in an article)
- The doctor never made a diagnosis of meningitis (when you have presented no evidence for that claim whatsoever)
okie wrote:He lied, either knowingly or unknowingly, either he lied knowing he was lying, or he really did not know what he was talking about. The second possibility is almost as bad as the first.
The news that Obama makes false statements is not a surprise to many of us, as many examples can be given, so this little incident is not an anomaly, but it is a very clearcut one that liberals try to explain away but simply cannot.
Now, I know many of you here will apparently defend Obama no matter how clear it is that the man makes false statements repeatedly. This is but one of many.
All of this, coming from you, is quite rich.