Nice Little Conservative Clip Job
"Nice Little Conservative Hit Job": And Also, Nice Little Conservative Clip Job
September 25, 2006
ThinkProgress
As ETP and TVNewser mentioned yesterday, Fox milked its Bill Clinton interview all day yesterday, including showing several clips including this one, which was also the top video on the Fox site (and about which ETP also wrote specifically yesterday). This clip has since had more than a million views (1,001,556 as of this morning, to be precise) and I think it's worth noting what was included in it ?- and what was left out:
CLINTON: But at least I tried. That's the difference in me and some, including all the right-wingers who are attacking me now. They ridiculed me for trying. They had eight months to try. They did not try. I tried. So I tried and failed.
The "I tried, and failed" is a pretty deliberate note to go out on ?- did you hear that, everybody? Clinton admits it! He failed! What was also deliberate was to have included it in the first place, because the "I tried and failed" was not the completion of a thought, but the beginning of a new one.
The full paragraph from ThinkProgress's unexpurgated transcript:
http://thinkprogress.org/clinton-interview
So I tried and failed. When I failed, I left a comprehensive anti-terror strategy and the best guy in the country, Dick Clarke, who got demoted.
Hmm, that leaves a sort of different impression, doesn't it? Too bad a million YouTube viewers didn't see that.
NB: Thoughts on the interview as a "conservative hit job" after the jump.
As for the allegation that this was a "conservative hit job" ?- Wallace has adopted a wide-eyed "don't look at me" position, claiming that "All I did was ask him a question" and that he was "I was utterly surprised by the tidal wave of details--emotion--and political attacks that followed." In fact, Wallace's so-called "non-confrontational question" was multipart, not only asking "Why didn't you do more to put bin Laden and Al Qaida out of business when you were president?" but also bringing up Somalia in 1993, the bombings of U.S. African embassies and the U.S.S. Cole, and brought up allegations raised by the book The Looming Tower, which is highly critical of Clinton in the pre-9/11 years. So it actually was very much a question that required breaking out element by element to properly answer, which is what Clinton said when he heard it ("Now, I will answer all those things on the merits, but first I want to talk about the context in which this arises"). As the conversation proceeded, Wallace several times tried to interject and interrupt, with Clinton responding like so: "You brought this up, so you'll get an answer."
Clinton also attacked the notion of fairness and balance on Fox in this (edited) exchange:
WALLACE: You don't think that's a legitimate question?
CLINTON: It was a perfectly legitimate question, but I want to know how many people in the Bush administration you asked this question of.
WALLACE: But, President Clinton, if you look at the questions here, you'll see half the questions are about [the Clinton Global Initiative]. I didn't think this was going to set you off on such a tear.
CLINTON: You launched it -- it set me off on a tear because you didn't formulate it in an honest way and because you people ask me questions you don't ask the other side.
The whole thing is really just a fascinating TV moment, and it's also fascinating to see Clinton go on the offensive that way (or, rather, defensive but it sure felt like an offense). The most amazing part was seeing him frankly articulate the subtext that is so often never spoken.
Wallace asked Clinton if he watched Fox News Sunday; to be honest, ETP typically does not. What we know of Chris Wallace we learned from his appearance on The Daily Show last year. We thought he was a bit of a weasel then, too.