dyslexia
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 01:08 pm
"common sense" would dictate that "everyone knows the sun rises every morning and sets every evening" Common sense tells us that and yet we all know that the sun does not rise every morning and set every evening because the earth simply rotates. Common sense is more like mass hysteria much of the time.
0 Replies
 
snood
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 01:11 pm
dang I must be hanging around here too much. that actually made sense to me...
0 Replies
 
xingu
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 01:14 pm
Momma wrote:
If I may ask a question of you, Xingu, since you started this thread. What is the use in starting these threads? I don't mean just "your side or views" I mean my side and all the sides inbetween?

I think you answered your own question.
Momma wrote:
I have learned a lot about science, history, and other things from many on these forums. I don't have the education some have and it's frustrating I know for some because my questions may seem pretty common sense to them.
0 Replies
 
megamanXplosion
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 01:18 pm
Quote:
Nowhere in the Bible is a cubit defined.


You need to read another book besides the Bible. The cubit is the length of the forearm of the person trying to measure a cubit. A cubit consists of two spans, which were essentially the distance from the tip of the pinky to the tip of the thumb when stretched out as far as possible. For me a cubit would be 15 inches (span is 7.5 inches), though Bible scholars typically put 17.5 inches as the measurement from ancient times. (I don't disagree with their estimate, my hands are fairly small.) It was horribly inaccurate (as you shall see below) but it was the only thing they had at the time.

By multiplying the amount of cubits for each dimension (L,W,H) against the 17.5 inches estimate by Bible scholars and dividing by 12 one can easily derive the amount of feet.

Length = (300 x 17.5) / 12 = 437.5 feet
Width = (50 x 17.5) / 12 = 72.9 feet
Height = (30 x 17.5) / 12 = 43.75 feet

If I were the one building the ark (15 inches per cubit), this is how big it would be...

Length = (300 x 15) / 12 = 375 feet
Width = (50 x 15) / 12 = 62.5 feet
Height = (30 x 15) / 12 = 37.5 feet

Quote:
You ignore that fact that maybe Noah's expertise with wood surpassed that of our today. Just as the pyramids and obelisks of Egypt are still today a wonder to modern architecture. Micro thin copper or aluminum could have been attached to the hull. The wood with some calking and putty and sap could have sealed the boat up quite nicely they did NOT have to have even one leak. The story does not mention that the boat leaked so they must have had that problem licked.


Where is the evidence that naval architecture was better several thousand years ago? With the ark so eloquently described in the Bible, don't you think modern ship builders would use that description to build their own ships? Why it did take so many thousands of years to learn how to harness electricity when the ancients knew how to harnass it? Is everyone in the world stupid except for Bible thumpers? You are making some far-fetched theories here. Proverbially, you are the squirrel who is about to break the ever-narrowing twig it walks on.

Quote:
The story does not mention that the boat leaked so they must have had that problem licked.


The story also doesn't mention the corpses floating around the boat either. I guess God had that problem licked.

Quote:
Noah was given the job of building the boat as an old man but he may have ALSO been a boat builder by partial trade considering they were near the mediterranean in Turkey.


Where are all of the other boats?

Quote:
Also the basin of the black sea is far below the sea level of the Mediterranean. (again something you haven't considered) So if the mediterranean was pouring into the black sea basin it would have looked like it was pouring out of the sky.


It would've looked like it was pouring from a certain direction. The story says it rained (water coming down everywhere), not poured (water coming down from one location).

Quote:
Noah may have lived for 600 years because of diet and lack of human pathogens. He may have eaten plants that are extinct now (mana or similar) for instance... that prolonged life sharply.


There is a native plant species in the Sinai peninsula called the tamarisk bush. The insects on the bush excrete sugary sap that then drops to the ground. When it is morning there is dew on the ground and the sap looks like the rest of the dew. When the Sun comes up and evaporates the dew the sap crystallizes and they become white, round, and flaky and looks like hoarfrost. The "raining from heaven" quote is symbolic of how the drops fell to the ground. The people who found them called them Man-hu (Manna), which literally meant "what is it?" Manna is nothing more than insect crap. And trust me, if that insect crap made people live longer it would be a very, very, profitable business.

The claim of extinct plant life is an unproven assertion that is not supported by the Bible or science. It is purely imaginary and is rightfully disregarded until you can provide evidence to support your assertion. And the existence of H heidelbergensis and other pathogens, as farmerman rightfully pointed out, disproves the remaining claim in the above quotation.

Quote:
Also when God says EVERY creature (clean and unclean) that does not mean ALL creatures. I bet you didn't consider that. (along with allot of this you have not considered)


You are correct that it may not have meant all creatures. You have now implicitly admitted the world-wide flood part is an exaggeration (you mentioned the Black Sea flood), explicitly stated the "every creature" part may have been an exaggeration, have retreated on the "rain" part like it was also an exaggeration, and one can only wonder: what makes you think the rest is not an exaggeration or a greatly warped retelling of an earlier myth? (Hint: "faith" is an excuse, not a reason.)

Quote:
Set you are interpreting the story again with a western mind and with a touch of Hollywood.


And you are interpreting the story again with an apologetic mind without a touch of skepticism.

Quote:
It does not have to be floating all this time. Who knows how they calked and puttied the boat. They may have had techniques that are LOST to todays boat builders. The USA has been building boats for 200 years? Noah's people had thousands of years of history.


And the Egyptians used UFO laser beams and grappling beams to build the pyramids. Are you even listening to yourself? All modern architecture is built upon the ideas of past civilizations. Noah's people may have had thousands of years of history but current civilization have been improving on the ideas from the thousands of years before it.

Quote:
With a bit of un-coerced brain storming solutions can be provided for most of your objections Set.


You are forcing your ideas to accomodate to the Bible rather than reality. That is quite coerced.

Quote:
But you would rather abruptly point out the "errors" in the story which I supply are errors in "your" understanding and not errors in the text.


He points them out because they are errors in the text.

Quote:
The only thing typical here is your complete inability to comprehend what has been said to you. The actual size of the boat doesn't matter--it is the proportions of the vessel which make it unseaworthy.

The rest of that is just more of your silly musings, for which you don't have the authority of the text of the bobble. In short, you just make sh!t up as you go along.


I agree.

Quote:
There's still that troubling habit you have of calling things you don't believe in, "horsie-poop" and the like, that would be hard to attach to the southern dialect thing...


The stories are "horsie-poop" though. I don't think he needs to apologize, or stop, calling things as they seem.

Quote:
Now this is funny. There were no human pathogens in those days. Mind you we are speaking of 2500 B.C. So I suppose no one died of any illness that was caused by bacteria or virus in those days. So when did bacterias and viruses that were deadly to humans first make their appearance?


When Jesus came about to blow his nasty breath in peoples' faces to make demons run out. How could you have missed this obvious answer!? Wink

Quote:
"common sense" would dictate that "everyone knows the sun rises every morning and sets every evening" Common sense tells us that and yet we all know that the sun does not rise every morning and set every evening because the earth simply rotates. Common sense is more like mass hysteria much of the time.


I agree. There is no such thing as common sense.
0 Replies
 
snood
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 01:29 pm
Quote:
The stories are "horsie-poop" though. I don't think he needs to apologize, or stop, calling things as they seem.


I didn't ask or expect an apology - we're dealin with Setanta here.

Hey, as long as everyone realizes "horsie-poop" and "poofery" are very subjective descriptions, and in no way sanctioned by any governing body...

I just opined it's unnecessary insult that lowers the discussion.
0 Replies
 
Arella Mae
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 01:45 pm
Thank you, Xingu.
0 Replies
 
ehBeth
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 02:39 pm
megamanXplosion, that was a marvellous post on the whole cubit +++ issue. Thanks!
0 Replies
 
Setanta
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 02:42 pm
Steve (as 41oo) wrote:
The Kim Jong Ill Freeway

Kim Ill Sung autobahn

Phuk Ill Baht motorway

just imagining, no offence to DRNK road engineers


South Korea, Buddy . . . South Korea . . . it's a whole 'nother experience . . . and the food's damned good, too . . .
0 Replies
 
RexRed
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 02:53 pm
Setanta wrote:
RexRed wrote:
Set you make a cubit large enough to make the boat the size of a football field... Nowhere in the Bible is a cubit defined. So you do not know how big the boat was. Yet you make it so enormous that it could not float. Typical...


The only thing typical here is your complete inability to comprehend what has been said to you. The actual size of the boat doesn't matter--it is the proportions of the vessel which make it unseaworthy.

The rest of that is just more of your silly musings, for which you don't have the authority of the text of the bobble. In short, you just make sh!t up as you go along.


Set, your arguments on Noah's Ark are cleverly conceived... but they seem to omit one thing...

The miracle of God...
0 Replies
 
ehBeth
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 02:57 pm
Rex - do you seriously not know the meaning of cubit?
0 Replies
 
BDV
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 03:00 pm
Another Arc story, dated 1699BC :

Gilgamesh Epic

In Gilgamesh's journey, he met Utnapishtim. The elderly Utnapishtim told Gilgamesh the story of the flood. Warned by a god, Utnapishtim had made an ark and sealed it with pitch. Then he made his family go in and he shut the door.

Utnapishtim's story says it rained six days; the water rose only to the roofs of the houses. After the waters receded, the Utnapishtim story described him releasing a dove, a sparrow and a crow.

megamanXplosion wrote:
Quote:
Nowhere in the Bible is a cubit defined.


You need to read another book besides the Bible. The cubit is the length of the forearm of the person trying to measure a cubit. A cubit consists of two spans, which were essentially the distance from the tip of the pinky to the tip of the thumb when stretched out as far as possible. For me a cubit would be 15 inches (span is 7.5 inches), though Bible scholars typically put 17.5 inches as the measurement from ancient times. (I don't disagree with their estimate, my hands are fairly small.) It was horribly inaccurate (as you shall see below) but it was the only thing they had at the time.

By multiplying the amount of cubits for each dimension (L,W,H) against the 17.5 inches estimate by Bible scholars and dividing by 12 one can easily derive the amount of feet.

Length = (300 x 17.5) / 12 = 437.5 feet
Width = (50 x 17.5) / 12 = 72.9 feet
Height = (30 x 17.5) / 12 = 43.75 feet

If I were the one building the ark (15 inches per cubit), this is how big it would be...

Length = (300 x 15) / 12 = 375 feet
Width = (50 x 15) / 12 = 62.5 feet
Height = (30 x 15) / 12 = 37.5 feet
.........
0 Replies
 
Setanta
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 03:00 pm
snood wrote:
I just opined it's unnecessary insult that lowers the discussion.


Hoist on your own petard--you have hurled vitriolic and childish insult at me often enough to be convicted by your criterion of having lowered many discussions. Your hypocricy in this matter is glaring and tedious. It is also not à propos, given that i've stuck to the subject with the exception of responding to MOAN's attempts to derail the dicsussion, and responding to the hatefulness which you and Intrepid seem incapable of resisting.

You've got a real pot/kettle problem . . .
0 Replies
 
Setanta
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 03:02 pm
RexRed wrote:
Setanta wrote:
RexRed wrote:
Set you make a cubit large enough to make the boat the size of a football field... Nowhere in the Bible is a cubit defined. So you do not know how big the boat was. Yet you make it so enormous that it could not float. Typical...


The only thing typical here is your complete inability to comprehend what has been said to you. The actual size of the boat doesn't matter--it is the proportions of the vessel which make it unseaworthy.

The rest of that is just more of your silly musings, for which you don't have the authority of the text of the bobble. In short, you just make sh!t up as you go along.


Set, your arguments on Noah's Ark are cleverly conceived... but they seem to omit one thing...

The miracle of God...


Boy, it sure takes you a long time to catch up to the rest of the class. Science is only concerned with naturalistic phenomena and naturalistic investigations and explanations thereof. If you invoke miracles by your imaginary friend, you place the discussion necessarily outside the pale of science. It may surprise you to learn that that is the point of this discussion.
0 Replies
 
Setanta
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 03:14 pm
BDV wrote:
Another Arc story, dated 1699BC :

Gilgamesh Epic

In Gilgamesh's journey, he met Utnapishtim. The elderly Utnapishtim told Gilgamesh the story of the flood. Warned by a god, Utnapishtim had made an ark . . . (etc., etc.)


Gilgamesh is the most commonly referred to possible source for the Hebrew flood story, and more likely than others because of the Babylonian captivity. The Akkadians (to whom bobble-thumpers common refer, erroneously, as "Babylonians") record several variations. [ulr=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noah%27s_ark#Other_flood_accounts]This section of Wikipedia's "Noah's Ark" page[/url] has severl references to other flood myths--although i would recommend researching them separately from this Wikipedia article. One significant circumstance which is missed by the Wikipedia article is that the Aryan tribes of the Meda and teh Pharsee (those who the Greeks referred to as Medes and Persians) had already settled in the Iranian plateau at the time that the earliest known versions of the flood account were recorded. There may, of course, have been earlier Akkadian traditions upon which those were based. But it is also worth noting that the Aryan tribes from among whom the Meda and Pharsee derived, before invading the Iranian plateau, resided in the region of the Caucasus Mountains, and the shores of the Black and Caspian Seas. For more than a century, it has been known that there is compelling geological evidence for a dramatic rise in the water levels of both the Black and Caspian Seas in the period immediately after the retreat of the last glaciation. Melt water from the massive ice cap was filling these depressions raidly with significant volume of water at a time when the weight of the ice sheet still tilted the nearby land up, preventing run off to west into what is now the Med.

On a related note, Rex is completely full of poop about the Med--there is no evidence that at any time it was at a higher elevation than the Black Sea. I mean, come on, fer chrissake--water empties from the Black Sea into the Med--does Rex mean to add to his already stunning list of absurdities a contention that it runs up-hill to get there? ! ? ! ?
0 Replies
 
RexRed
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 03:15 pm
ehBeth wrote:
Rex - do you seriously not know the meaning of cubit?


I was taught that the actual length of a "Biblical" cubit is debatable. I may be wrong. Show me in the "Bible" where a cubit is defined...
0 Replies
 
snood
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 03:16 pm
Setanta wrote:
snood wrote:
I just opined it's unnecessary insult that lowers the discussion.


Hoist on your own petard--you have hurled vitriolic and childish insult at me often enough to be convicted by your criterion of having lowered many discussions. Your hypocricy in this matter is glaring and tedious. It is also not à propos, given that i've stuck to the subject with the exception of responding to MOAN's attempts to derail the dicsussion, and responding to the hatefulness which you and Intrepid seem incapable of resisting.

You've got a real pot/kettle problem . . .


Oh Setanta - I'm having a stellar moment here, and even you can't mar it....

You will never admit being wrong, anyway, so what's the point of trying to talk to someone who thinks they're never wrong?
0 Replies
 
megamanXplosion
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 03:18 pm
BDV wrote:
Another Arc story, dated 1699BC :

Gilgamesh Epic

In Gilgamesh's journey, he met Utnapishtim. The elderly Utnapishtim told Gilgamesh the story of the flood. Warned by a god, Utnapishtim had made an ark and sealed it with pitch. Then he made his family go in and he shut the door.

Utnapishtim's story says it rained six days; the water rose only to the roofs of the houses. After the waters receded, the Utnapishtim story described him releasing a dove, a sparrow and a crow.

megamanXplosion wrote:
(clipped...)


I am aware of the Epic of Gilgamesh. I also think it is the origin of the Ark of Noah story. It should also be pointed out that the ancient Egyptians had a celebration every year after the Nile river flooded (it helped plants grow and fed the people) called "Argha-Noa." Sound familiar? Wink
0 Replies
 
Setanta
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 03:20 pm
snood wrote:
You will never admit being wrong, anyway, so what's the point of trying to talk to someone who thinks they're never wrong?


I trust you were looking in a mirror when you composed that . . .
0 Replies
 
RexRed
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 03:24 pm
Noah's Flood


The Black Sea basin was a valley below the sea level of the Mediterranean.

If you were in the "valley" when the Black Sea began to fill you would have been below sea level if the waters were rising.

Seeing a water fall, the size of Niagara, would have seemed, from below, like it was pouring out of the sky.
0 Replies
 
BDV
 
  1  
Reply Fri 7 Jul, 2006 03:25 pm
I wasn't given it up as evidence, more to show the the following:

1-As you can see the bible says it rains for 40 days, this story 6.
2-His family closes the door, the bible says god closed the door of the arc.
3-The water covered the roofs, the bibles flood story says it covered the mountains.

Surely this would the last evidence you would use to provide proof of a world wide flood?

megamanXplosion wrote:
BDV wrote:
Another Arc story, dated 1699BC :

Gilgamesh Epic

In Gilgamesh's journey, he met Utnapishtim. The elderly Utnapishtim told Gilgamesh the story of the flood. Warned by a god, Utnapishtim had made an ark and sealed it with pitch. Then he made his family go in and he shut the door.

Utnapishtim's story says it rained six days; the water rose only to the roofs of the houses. After the waters receded, the Utnapishtim story described him releasing a dove, a sparrow and a crow.

megamanXplosion wrote:
(clipped...)


I am aware of the Epic of Gilgamesh. I also think it is the origin of the Ark of Noah story. It should also be pointed out that the ancient Egyptians had a celebration every year after the Nile river flooded (it helped plants grow and fed the people) called "Argha-Noa." Sound familiar? Wink
0 Replies
 
 

Related Topics

New Propulsion, the "EM Drive" - Question by TomTomBinks
The Science Thread - Discussion by Wilso
Why do people deny evolution? - Question by JimmyJ
Are we alone in the universe? - Discussion by Jpsy
Fake Science Journals - Discussion by rosborne979
Controvertial "Proof" of Multiverse! - Discussion by littlek
 
  1. Forums
  2. » Bible vs. Science
  3. » Page 25
Copyright © 2025 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 1.86 seconds on 03/17/2025 at 10:36:09