maporsche wrote:Finn dAbuzz wrote:The Right is evil; The Right is stupid and incompetent.
Why can't the right be all 3? I'm not saying they are, but I don't see how any of them are exclusive of the others.
OR
Since the right is made up of many different people, is it not possible that portions of the right, sub-categories of the right, can be one or more of these 3 things.
The concept of evil implies awareness at a fairly high level.
It is difficult to reconcile evil with stupidity and ignorance.
Evil can be incompetent, but most of those who argue the Right is evil, do so because of a belief that these evil people are diabolically clever and capable of the most byzantine of plots.
If George Bush is a moron, then it's quite a stretch to suggest that he is evil. If Cheney is the evil puppet master manipulating Bush then it's pretty tough to argue that he is either stupid or incompetent.
Of course the mass of people who either consider themselves members of The Right or who are categorized as such are not uniform in their capabilities or inclinations. So, yes we can say that The Right is made up of the evil, the stupid and the incompetent. However, in this vein we must also be prepared to say that The Right is made up of the virtuous, the brilliant and the competent. Likewise we must be prepared to say that the Left incorporates all of these characteristics - good and bad.
The truth is that critics of The Right desire the ability to inflict maximum rhetorical damage on their target.
Being sanctimonious Leftists, The Right must be evil.
Being smug elitist Leftists, The Right must be stupid.
Interestingly enough, the Rightists who detest The Left don't fall afoul of this logic trap. They believe the Left is evil and that they are diabolically clever and capable of injecting their evil into American society.
But then Right-wingers don't have an obsession with being "smart," the way Left-wingers do.