Cycloptichorn wrote:Quote:What we do have is a quote of his wife saying he said it
Ah ah. You mean his estranged ex-wife. Slight difference. She actually claimed she 'inferred' it from statements that he made.
No, I mean his wife at the time. Her comment that she supposed she would have to move with him indicates that much. ("
And then I'd probably have to go too.")
Quote:Quote:his subsequent denial that she even gave that magazine an interview
Which he may not have known about as they were seperated at the time
Then he ought to not state as fact what he knows nothing about. And the fact that he did demonstrates his lack of credibility, as I said.
This is what Baldwin said: "
I never said I'd leave the country, and my wife never heard of Focus magazine and never talked to them." Yet his wife indeed had heard of Focus magazine, and did talk to them.
Whether he actually said he'd leave the country or not, he has demonstrated time and again his propensity for talking out of his a$$.
Quote:Quote: and then his later admission that she did.
Which is the right thing to do once he found out the interview was real.
Bully for him. Doesn't make his prior remark more accurate.
Quote:Quote:His claiming she did not give the interview was inaccurate, and therefore I believe the accuracy of the rest of what he said is called into question.
Tell me, given the inaccurate claims in the past, how do you feel about the Bush administration these days? You're all wet. Fox mentioned yet another non-fact as if it were actually a fact. The point that it isn't really known whether or not he said it doesn't make it okay to assert that he said it. It's the same kind of stupid reasoning that lead to the Iraq war, and it doesn't surprise me to see parrots echoing it in your caucus.
Cycloptichorn
Nonsense. I never said Baldwin lied. I said he has a propensity for bombastic remarks, for talking out of his ass, and for being flat wrong about whether or not his wife gave that interview. And for him to claim that she never talked to the magazine, when she did, leads me to believe it more likely than not that she said what the magazine quoted her as saying (and to disbelieve anything he has to say about the matter). Which I understand is her impression of what he said. I'm not alleging that her interpretation is fact, I'm saying you cannot impugn Foxy's credibility for her claim that Baldwin made this statement, as quoted by his wife.