blatham wrote:"Physical attacks"!? Could you please get a slight grip on the proper use of language. She had two pumpkin pies tossed at her, one of which caught her shoulder. You'll recall at the time that she described the pumpkin pie throwers as "terrorists" (another wonderful example of precision in language use). I heartily approve of pie tossing at anyone and everyone, including our Canadian Prime Minister (liberal) who got one several years ago. Every politician and pundit ought to get at least one pie a year in the kisser, just for the sake of humility.
Now, shouting down a voice with which you disagree, particularly in a university setting, is not an act with which I agree. But if you think about it, MM, is there ANY individual you've seen on TV in discussion who is more frequently guilty of shouting down anyone else talking with whom she disagrees than Coulter?
As much as my heart wants to agree with blatham about the pies, my brain leads me towards the point made by MM.
Is there any doubt that Ann Coulter has received death threats?
I think that if I were in her position or the position of any other celebrity, I would be very alarmed to find someone rushing at me with a large object in their hand. It's not as if these targets have any time to assess what is about to happen to them and say:
"Oh well, it's only a pie, and this guy looks pretty nice so I'm sure it's not a Broken Glass Merengue."
The only way these idiots can pull off their stunts is to get very close to their target and then rush towards them. I saw a clip of Bill Gates getting hit by a pie and his attacker did not have a wry grin on his face as he rushed forward, his teeth were clenched and bared and his eyes wide open. It was pretty clear that he was pumped with adrenaline.
I would have been very alarmed by him rushing at me.
It
is a physical attack, albeit one of no physical harm if the "pie" consists merely of whip or shaving cream. (I suspect that getting hit in the face with an actual pumpkin or apple pie might hurt a bit).
So as much as I enjoy the sight of a celebrity with a whipped cream pie dripping of his or her face, I can't excuse the action as simply some merry prank. I don't know if there was ever a Golden Age when people could trust someone rushing towards them with a pie shaped object, but I know it's not the case now.
I don't think I'd send the pie-throwers to jail, but if one of the celebrities bodyguards coldcocks the guy as he rushes forward, I don't think I'd send him to jail either.
As for pie-throwers as terrorists? No way ---simply attention seeking clowns.
As for shouting down other speakers, I'm afraid you haven't studied your enemy very closely. That is really not Coulter's MO and there are many more pundits who regularly employ the tactic: Eleanor Clift comes to mind.