goodfielder wrote:blatham wrote:"...in the instinctive belief of many ordinary Americans - the default mode of humanity is to become Americans." (Anatol Lieven, America Right or Wrong, page 66)
Thus, all American policy ought to come to fruition, any contestation or disagreement with American policy is mistaken or traitorous, and any and all wars begun by America ought to be won by America regardless of any other factor. What could be more clear?
At the moment yes. It seems that the Bushii have developed that idea and taken it to ridiculous heights but would that have pertained under President Kerry? Did it pertain under Clinton? Will it pertain under the next President Clinton?
gf
It isn't that this Bush administration has 'developed' this presumption of America's place in the world. This is a modern face on an old creature, but yes, it is an extreme version. Jesse Helms speaking to the UN
Quote:"...states, above all the United States, that are democratic, and act in the cause of liberty, possess unlimited authority, subject to no external control, to carry out military adventures."
But preceding this modern era we see Woodrow Wilson, during WW1, saying
Quote:"America had the infinite privilege of fulfilling her destiny and saving the world".
The messianist nationalism we see in full bloom presently is a story that goes back to the settlement of America and the revolution. One can draw a pretty clear parallel (and many historians have) between the protestant renewal movements common to American history (our version of bare-bones faith is the true version and it is our duty to spread it throughout the world, overtuning the old, jaded, encumbered and false christian pretender faiths) and the nationalism spawned of violent revolution. The consequence being a long-standing myth framework of something like "We are the Champions of the world - about politics and about god".
And it is - in odd contrast to America's own myths - often really quite a severe nationalism demanded of the citizenry with intolerance of dissent a central feature. Even De Toqueville comments here
Quote:"I know of no country where there is so little true independence of mind and freedom of discussion as in America...The majority raises very formidable barriers to the liberty of opinion; within these barriers and author may write whatever he pleases, but he will repent if he ever step beyond them."
So this isn't a Bush or a Republican or a 21st century phenomenon. This is merely a pinnacle of the lunatic aspects - a sort of full moon period for America.