I had a disappointing twitter exchange with Corey Robin. Corey is a guy I respect. He's an historian and I've read his most recent book. Here's the sequence of tweets:
Quote:corey robin
@CoreyRobin
· Apr 13
Watch every single person who complained that Bernie's supporters are a cult marching in lock step with the dear leader get furious that his supporters are not in fact a cult marching in lock step with the dear leader, that they make their own decisions, in their own time.
Quote:the brittle hum of the republic
@BernieLatham
Apr 13
Another way to frame this, Corey, is to question why those who insisted on Bernie's unique and life-long integrity re forwarding a socialist ethos might now perceive this step by him as something different and less an instance of that same integrity we might wish to duplicate.
Quote:corey robin
@CoreyRobin
· Apr 13
Replying to @BernieLatham
I suspect many of Sanders's supporters will see his move not as a departure from his integrity but very much in keeping with his integrity. That doesn't mean they will reach the same conclusion he did. Their sense of integrity may in fact be different from his.
Quote:the brittle hum of the republic
@BernieLatham
Apr 13
Fair enough. But given Bernie's stated rationale here and given the catastrophic danger of another Trump term I do not comprehend how such an abstract position can be defensible.
Then here's his response I find disappointing
Quote:corey robin
@CoreyRobin
· Apr 13
Replying to @BernieLatham
Just out of curiosity: How many phone calls have you made for Biden today? Since you opened this whole discussion on the question of integrity, doing that—making calls for Biden—would seem to be the most in keeping with your goals
This seems a bit cheap on Corey's part. My point had been that there's an apparent inconsistency from the claim that "Bernie is unique in the historical integrity of his political decisions which is part of why we support him" to "our integrity now leads us to break with him". Corey then sets up parameters which, he implies, if I don't fall within them, might disallow me to opine about integrity at all in this matter. I responded as follows:
Quote: the brittle hum of the republic
@BernieLatham
Apr 13
To satisfy your 'curiosity', none. I'm no longer living in the US but have returned to Canada (I was active during the decade down south). But US politics/culture have been my main area of interest and study for forty years. I've read The Reactionary Mind, for example.
It would have been easy enough to paste in some lie but I prefer not to be that sort of asshole. The interaction ended there.