@georgeob1,
georgeob1 wrote:
Free college means that the government pays for it. What the government pays for, it controls. Academics and teachers will become civil servants (probably unionized) and the 1quality of scholarship and education for all will suffer.
(Higher) education is already structured in a way that caters to a superficial approach to knowledge. Students want easy hoops to jump through that give them the credentials they need to go get jobs and make money. Those who get hired cater to this student desire, and people who are critical of the dogmatism either get promoted into positions where they can express critique or they fall through the cracks of the system as others who are more friendly to the BS are embraced and given roles catering to the students.
The unions are already a problem to the extent they drive up salaries so that self-marketing experts compete for the jobs instead of those who truly love education so much they are willing to work for peanuts. Public funding used to be such that practically anyone could get a job in academia and get by, but then the trend grew of seeking external funding to supplement public funding, which led to the widespread cultural belief that public funding is insufficient.
That public belief is key to understanding where we are now. Try to grasp this very clearly:
it is not public funding that's insufficient; it is those working for the system that are deeming it insufficient in order to press for more money that is the problem. If everyone involved would simply work harder at lowering salaries than raising them, those who are in it for the money would go find other jobs or learn to make do with less if they truly believe in education.
Still, nothing can ever stop people with money from trying to invest their money in getting better education for their kids and themselves. So there will always be private schools and private funding sources pulling strings to attempt to weight the system to their advantage in various ways.
The thing about education is that knowledge and skills can be reproduced limitlessly by willing people, and that is the biggest threat to people who want to maintain a social hierarchy with themselves higher up on the soci0-economic pyramid. So, for whatever reason, there will always be bad students and bad information doing the senseless job of ruining some educational situations so others will only be available at a premium, either by paying higher tuition (& finding grants) or by moving to more expensive parts of town (and thus paying more taxes and more to home sellers, realtors, contractors, etc. etc.)
It would be great if everyone would just get on board with giving and getting great education at a minimum of cost, but that conflicts with what so many business people are trying to achieve with economic society in so many subtle and not-so-subtle ways.