@georgeob1,
Quote:Do you feel the same way about the treatment of conservative speakers on a fairly large number of university campuses?
Let's set aside the difference between these two issues. They are very similar in that both are key rights issues and both (by the stipulation of your question) occurred in a university setting (perhaps not your favorite human institution which may be why you've framed your question as you have).
We've established the "right to a lawyer" as a fundamental civil/human right, likewise the "right to free speech". Both, we could note, are intended to address social inequalities in power/wealth to arrive at more consistent and fair judicial procedures. And like all "rights", they are the product of a social contract. A "right" becomes so when enough of us agree it is so.
Now, after two paragraphs of introductory fun, let's get to your query. The answer is... sometimes.
First, I think there is no case where a right to a lawyer can justifiably be negated. And I think anyone behaving so as to weaken this right is a ******* idiot too dull to appreciate a right that applies to them and which is vitally important as a key right.
Second, I think there are cases where speech acts are justifiably restricted. For example, a truck moving slowly down a city street with one of those huge Hollywood/Nazi style loudspeakers blaring out the voice of Ann Coulter urging citizens to round up and murder all the Jews. Or Ann Coulter speaking from a stage (anywhere) promoting the same thing. On the other hand, however, there are very, very few such egregious cases that I have ever encountered. But there are some that happen now and again which head too closely to speech meant to foment hatreds of persons or groups. If I was in charge of such a venue (
at university particularly) I would want speech liberty to be given maximal latitude. You know, the way it is at Falwell's university. So I wouldn't permit a speaker to be blocked by those who disagree with content almost always. And my opinion of those who attempt such blockades is not high because, again, they are working against themselves by diminishing a key civil/human right. (Protests are, of course, fine being instances of speech liberty as well)
And later today, I'm going to fill you all in on my theory that God is left-handed and how this explains
a lot. Stay tuned.