dyslexia wrote:I suppose I am the only one on the planet who finds the Iraqi election to be interesting but puzzling at the same time. I can only guess what this election foretells about he future of Iraq and I certainly don't guess that because there was an election there will be a democracy (or even that there should be a democracy) I am also just guessing (blame my inherent stupidty) that in the best interest of the Iraqi people a benevolent dictatship would prove the most valuable in securing civil rights for the people. I find it most interesting that most everyone (from A2k posters to White House pundits are able to rejoice and/or denouce the voter turnout as if they had some inspired vision of what it all may mean in the years to come.
Why not a benevolent dictatorship for the US and Europe? If its good for the Iraqis, why not everyone else?
Of course there is no such thing as a benevolent dictatorship. Lord Action's observation about the corrupting influence of power was quite insightful.
The only realistic alternative to the fantasy of the Good King is spreading power out among the citizens of a state. I suppose it's a sign of post modern sophistication to question whether or not democracy is right for a given people. Of course such post modernist sophisticates tend to reside in democracies themselves.
There seems to be a school of thought (of which you are a student) that feels compelled to note that today's election is but the first, and quite possibly the only, step in a process of democratization. It's a valid point, but I question the intent of making it when it is accompanied by a simultaneous desire to dampen enthusiasm.
If I had lost the use of my legs for a long period of time and through some modern medical miracle regained the ability to stand and take a step, I doubt I would appreciate the advise of others to not get so full of myself for a first step, that there was no guarantee that I would take any additional steps, and that in any case, I was in for a tough period of rehabilitation. I might want to throw something at anyone who opined that there was even a question as to whether or not I
should walk again.
The Iraqis, and those who wish them well are more than justified in celebrating this first step, regardless of what the final outcome may be.