@Helloandgoodbye,
Quote:Assuming Your religious position is true, and that After a person dies and their flesh has rotted away along with the horrible stench is gone too..... there is nothing.?
Why is this a problem?
Quote:So in other words, it’s all for nothing?
No, that is just your perspective, not mine. Again - if you can't find meaning in this life, how do you think you'll find it by living forever?
Quote:Any meaning you find will ultimately be trumped by nothingness Is what you preach it seems.
Uh - this is an incredibly unhappy outlook on life.
Meaning in the here and now, meaning for ten years, meaning in how you live your life, meaning in the values you hold, meaning in the relationships you have, meaning in where you are going / the journey you are on etc...are not trumped by death. They end when you die. The path you took was what is / was filled with meaning. That is not at all the same thing as being trumped by death.
Now, if you want to hold that 'they are indeed trumped by nothingness' - that is up to you. For me, that perspective is needless. I can't see any value in the perspective.
One of the great failings of religion is that it tries to build people up by first tearing them down (all are
born sinners, etc), and holds both reward and fear out as motivation to better yourself.
While it works, I don't see it as a positive way to promote self esteem. One of the issues with that being, people with truly high self esteem (rather than ego) are usually amongst the best of people there are. Those with low, vary widely.
So I prefer the perspective that all men can better themselves. That everyone is capable of finding meaning. And that it takes work (both internal and external) to do so.