@blatham,
I have always found her incredibly flat - smart and flat. Again, think Elizabeth May. Canada's smartest politician by far - she's been acknowledged as a parliamentary leader by all of the parties - superb technical debater - but just not there as a campaigner.
Would I vote for Ms. Warren if I was a voter in the US? I'd have to, but I sure wouldn't be happy that the party had selected her.
I was talking about the need for the Democrats to find a young, smart AND charismatic candidate years ago. Neither of the major US parties seems to have a gift for bringing young candidates up through the ranks. I think it's a horrible gap.