I'm also (you already know this, I think) am rather odd. I took a lot of people off my list because I don't like the team as a whole (a good reason as players and coaches affect production of other players) or because I don't like some particular player for being a gigantic jerk, if I happen to know about that.
My sports interest started way early, as a romantic fantasy as a teenage girl - I fell in love with horse racing for one horse, for football with one player at a school I then liked halfway across the US, baseball as a sport because of specific players that I barely remember now, my being a teen a long time ago - I liked baseball on tv as a pre-teen, 1950. Read a lot of sports story type books back then.
Point being, I'm not as much about winning myself in a fantasy game, as I am for the stories, plus then maybe doing well. I take silly chances. I'm presently second in fantasy baseball, this the last regular week, but I'll never be first, this year, Gargamel is way ahead of all of us and deserves to be. Maybe I'll come out well on the playoff, but he's been best for weeks and weeks.
Still, I'll think about it. Might take a week. I'll let you know one way or the other.