http://secureliberty.org/index.php/2005/03/07/sgrena_car_shooting
Sgrena Car Shooting
I've been waiting for more information to filter in on this whole situation, and believe that now is the time to comment. Here's the basic background summary (H/T Rusty):
BAGHDAD, Iraq (CNN) -- U.S. soldiers attempted to warn the occupants of a car carrying a freed Italian journalist before troops opened fire, killing a bodyguard and wounding the reporter, multinational officials said Friday night.
Giuliana Sgrena, a 56-year-old reporter for the leftist Italian newspaper Il Manifesto, and three Italian security officers were in a car headed to Baghdad International Airport when they approached a checkpoint, Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi said. Look at what she has to say about the ordeal. (H/T Jawa Report)
***
U.S. troops "attempted to warn the driver to stop by hand and arm signals, flashing white lights, and firing warning shots in front of the car," the statement said. "When the driver didn't stop, the soldiers shot into the engine block, which stopped the vehicle."
***
The car approached a checkpoint, at night, and refused to stop. Soldiers shot at the engine block. Seems quite reasonable to me. Given Sgrena's sympathy for the terrorists, and hatred of the U.S., some see her captivity as a hoax. Look at what she has to say about her ordeal.
What did your captors tell you when you were hostage?
***
That I needed to help them to ask [Silvio] Berlusconi to withdraw the troops. They saw all what happens in Italy, demonstrations against the occupation, demonstrations for my liberation. And so they [became] aware that I was really working against the occupation and people were supporting me and so they told me: "We have seen that you are very appreciated in Italy". And that helped me to be freed.
***
She's awfully friendly to her captors, don't you think? She goes on to say she can't be sure that the attack was deliberate. But she also said this:
"Everyone knows that the Americans do not like negotiations to free hostages, and because of this I don't see why I should exclude the possibility of me having been the target," she said.
***
And writing in her left-wing Il Manifesto newspaper, she said upon her release her kidnappers warned her to be careful 'because there are Americans who don't want you to go back'."
***
Give me a break. This is a left wing fantasy. They drove too fast through Baghdad and tried to run through a security checkpoint without stopping. Given the threat of car bombs, the U.S. military had no choice but to fire on the car.
Sgrena recounts her story again as translated by CNN (H/T Captain Ed).
***
The car kept on the road, going under an underpass full of puddles and almost losing control to avoid them. We all incredibly laughed. It was liberating. Losing control of the car in a street full of water in Baghdad and maybe wind up in a bad car accident after all I had been through would really be a tale I would not be able to tell. Nicola Calipari sat next to me. The driver twice called the embassy and in Italy that we were heading towards the airport that I knew was heavily patrolled by U.S. troops. They told me that we were less than a kilometer away...when...I only remember fire. At that point, a rain of fire and bullets hit us, shutting up forever the cheerful voices of a few minutes earlier.
***
Sounds like the U.S. version of events with some spin. Car going very fast, at night, on a dangerous, heavily patrolled road, and it refuses to stop. She assumes that the military had been advised that they would be travelling that road, if so, why would they be going so fast and why wouldn't they stop? They knew U.S. troops patrolled the road, wouldn't they anticipate a need to stop? Even if the Italians did notify the U.S. military, there's no way that car is going to just cruise through a checkpoint. It just doesn't add up.