Fortunately, I have taken said burden upon myself to think of alternatives, and I'm far from the only one. But let's go line-by-line just for fun:
Quote:We never should have gone to war in Iraq in the first place
Self-explanatory. The contradictory evidence to the claims of WMD which were used to justify the war should have been examined in greater detail. The UN weapons inspectors who claimed there were no WMD in Iraq should have been given more time. Overall, we should have been more cautious before rushing into things; and myself and many like me were saying so at the time.
Quote:we never should have disbanded the Iraqi army
Yeah, this was just a dumb move. Iraq was already experiencing unemployment problems due to the war, so we take a few dozen thousand trained troops and tell them they are fired. Then we spend huge amounts of money to train NEW troops up. Right. The overwhelming body of thought is against this decision.
Quote:we never should have paid enormous sums to American companies to do work in Iraq
This is the crux of many of our problems in Iraq today. Instead of copying our previous successes in rebuilding Germany and Japan using a huge amount of local labor and organization, we have decided that the profits from this war rebuilding should all go to American companies.
This stirs up a lot of discontent in Iraq, as the US gov't seems to be doing more to help rich stockholders in the US than the Iraqi people themselves. Unemployment in Iraq has at times over the last year been as high as 60% of the populace; a man who has nothing to do will turn to trouble eventually. When this unemployed Iraqi, who had a job before we came, sees a group of contractors going by (who are getting paid 200k to do the same things the Iraqi would do for 30k) what do you think goes through his mind?
We easily could have set up a system which puts Iraqis themselves to work rebuilding their own society, but we chose not to in order to give higher profits to American companies. This has built a lot of resentment amongst the populace.
Quote: we never should have snubbed the rest of the world when it came to Iraq;
Self-explanatory; alienating those who we desperately need as allies, as well as potential trade and investment opportunities which have been soured by popular world dissent to our imperialism.
Quote:we never should have put idiots in charge of rebuilding the infrastructure of Iraq;
Once again, self-explanatory. Give me a day or so and I'll track down a few stories on the 20-something college graduates which were handed the reigns to the Iraqi economy and screwed it up immensly, to the tune of billions of dollars simply 'lost.'
Quote:we should have seen the insurgency coming
I know I did. Those that predicted the 'open arms of Iraqis strewing flowers' were and are fools who know
nothing about psychology or sociology.
Quote:we should have used adequate numbers of troops
Once again self-explanatory. Those who insisted we needed more troops at the beginning of the war were either ignored or fired. The idea that one could effectively control a semi-hostile population of over 25 million with less than 150k troops is idiotic. The failure of the admin. to adjust to this obvious fact is one of the biggest marks against them.
We should have waited for more international support by simply delaying our start of the war until weapons inspections could have been completed, or not gone to war at all based upon the (assuredly) negative results which those inspections would have come up with. There was no reason for the haste we displayed, and it is costing us now.
Quote:we shouldn't be torturing men and children who are innocent in Abu Ghraib.
I'd like to hear someone argue
for this one. No argument is needed on my end on how it should have been different; just a little f*cking decency.
I highly doubt that making ANY of those changes would have lead to the deaths of MORE people, or made things worse in Iraq in any way.
Cycloptichorn