@farmerman,
Quote:Its probably because most English writers get paid by the word, and they seek to enrich themselves by each draft.
Not so the best English writers. You are comparing "most English writers" to what you consider one of the best American writers. Which is a sophistry playing on the unwary not grasping the significance of the "most". I would guess that most American writers get paid by the word and judging by the flummery I have seen it certainly shows. And, from what I gather, Mr Clemens was skint and didn't fancy laying railway tracks or clearing forests. He wrote for money. Why are you distinguishing between "by the word" and "by the book". More sophistry for the unwary. And anyway Mr Clemens was a journalist and would know everything there is to know about being paid by the word.
And never trust a man with a tash (mouse) my father often said, especially a tash like the one Mr Clemens liked to sport. All shaved and clipped into shape in the salon with a towel round his neck and a questionable looking gentleman faffing around him and flattering the **** out of him. That being one way of turning a trick.
Quote:Clemens could say, in a single , comma-free phrase, what took several of your literary heros , several chapters to saythe same thing.
It would be good of you to provide a couple of examples. I have met ladies, not a few, who could say with one slightly raised eyebrow more than the sum total of all the knowledge and wisdom of the world. At some points at least. And whatever Mr Clemens said in a single, comma free phrase, was also at a similar point in time.
It is also possible, possibly probably, that the "several chapters" you refer to were saying something beyond your intellectual reach.
But an example or two of the comma-free phrases would be useful to our understanding in such an erudite and esteemed coffee-house as this one. One wouldn't wish our fragrant and estimable hostess to be discovered presiding over dock-yard talk. And that is what assertions amount to not matter how carefully disguised. And yours are blatant.
Quote:"Fine writing" is oft confused with depth, and humor is oft confused with banal. However, in almost all cases, Clemens was the originator of the thought.
Again, to labour the point, what thought did Mr Clemens originate?