@hawkeye10,
In an earlier post of yours, you said this:
Quote:You will now be pressured to get the guy into trouble with the law if you tell anyone in authority, so if you dont want him to get into trouble you should stop talking to people in your real life about it
To tell someone in a state of emotional turmoil--turmoil about anything--that they should "stop talking to people in their real life about it" is about the worse advice that anyone could give that person. People in distress need others they can turn to for support, to use as sounding boards, to help them more calmly evaluate situations, and to help them sort out what they are feeling. To suggest that they bottle up the turmoil and suffer in silence, is downright harmful.
Furthermore, your assumption that, "you will now be pressured to get the guy into trouble with the law" is absurd. Why would anyone pressure her to do that? The friend in the car with her would certainly be unlikely to do that--the friend, who was, in effect, a witness to what happened, did not think anything harmful was taking place, so why would she suddenly pressure her, after the fact, to report it to the police? And why would any other friends pressure her to report it either? Would reporting it help her clarify anything in her own mind? Someone in a rape crisis center would also be unlikely to pressure her to do anything regarding reporting a possible rape, since their purpose is to offer support, and they leave decisions regarding legal action entirely up to the client.
So, I couldn't disagree with you more regarding the advice you have given Dosed. People in a state of emotional turmoil or emotional distress need people they can trust that they can turn to for support and help. Their own welfare should be their primary concern. They need people they can talk to. Any possible issues about getting another party "into trouble with the law" should not be taking center stage. Dosed is fully in control of whether
she wants to become involved in any legal situations, and those who care about her will understand and respect that. Telling people to distrust others, at a time when they may need them the most, is not at all helpful.
Quote:Dosed must if she is American understand the full potential impact upon both her and the guy of talking about this event to anyone in authority or in the mental health system, as the american establishment is all too willing to remove from her her right to have any say in how this event is dealt with....there are often mandatory report laws, there are university (not sure if she is at university)polices that will mandate that those who violate sexual assault laws be removed from the university, their are mandatory arrest laws and mandatory prosecution policies.
Your above statement is filled with misinformation--and, again, your promulgating such misinformation is downright harmful to anyone reading this thread. There are
no mandatory reporting laws that would apply in Dosed's situation--Dosed is not a child who has been sexually abused, she is a 20 year old college student, who is presumably quite legally competent to protect her own interests. Mandatory reporting primarily refers to the obligation, on the part of state designated mandatory reporters, to inform protective services in cases of abuse of minors or the elderly. Again, you are inappropriately warning Dosed to be fearful of the very people she should be trusting at a time she needs them--including mental health professionals.
You must be completely out of touch with the American legal and mental health system if you don't understand that
licensed mental health professionals must maintain confidentiality, and confidentiality is a matter that is taken very seriously. She can tell such mental health professionals, including those in the university counseling service, pretty much anything, short of her plans to murder someone,
and they must maintain the confidentiality of that information.They have no interest in whether she presses charges against someone else for rape, robbery, fraud, or any other crime under the sun which might have been committed against her--their interest is in helping her to deal with, and understand, her emotional state.
And they maintain confidentiality of the therapeutic relationship and the information they receive.
Universities, who notoriously sweep incidents of sexual assaults under the rug, have no "mandatory prosecution policies" and there are "no mandatory arrest laws" binding them--what on earth are you talking about? Universities have an obligation to warn students if a dangerous person is on the campus, or to notify the police in case of an imminent danger, but that has nothing to do with what you are talking about, and those things would happen only
after a student specifically notifies them about such a situation and
asks them to take action.
I think that others reading this thread should understand that what you are offering is not just poor advice, it's misinformation which is downright harmful. When people need help, they should seek it, and tactics designed to irrationally frighten them about doing that are really uncalled for.