@dizzy phil,
dizzy wrote:I'm sorry Didymos but I have to disagree with you entirely. To start I offer my condolences that your ability to have non sporadic lucid dreams has not given you the opportunity to delve into the realms of your imagination to either gain insight or simply to ore at the splendiferous marvel that is dreaming and the mind.
Oh, it is a marvel, however strange, those lucid dreams. But do they offer an opportunity to "delve into the realms of your imagination"? I do not think so. An example will come further down the page.
There are two kinds of lucid dreams. The sort where you, once the dreaming has already begun, take some degree of control over the "you" in the dream and the imagery. The other sort, and in my experience far more rare, is when you go directly from being awake to lucid dreaming.
Going back to my Psychology 101 class, I recall something about what the professor said dreams most likely are: somewhat-randomly (not totally random, perhaps a cleaning out of thoughts and images familiar, not unlike computers dumbing useless information) firing neurons in the brain. Lucid dreaming is simply taking some degree of control over those neurons.
It's something like day dreaming except you have less control and the experience is a great deal more vivid.
dizzy wrote:Have you worked out, which is the primary reality if a primary reality could be stated and have you also concluded beyond any doubt that the waking life is the life we should focus on. It is a very bold statement that you have made and I feel it would be a dishonour to the dreams of everyone if you didn't explain yourself further especially how you came to this most grievous misjudgement.
Are you asking me: 'which should be the focus of human life: waking life or the dream state?'
Yeah, waking life is where it's at. If nothing else, you spend more time in waking life. More importantly, waking life is essential to human life whereas lucid dreams are not essential to human life. Further, the content of dreams, lucid or otherwise, is derived from waking life: the content of waking life is not derived from dreams, except in some cases of art, like that one Kurosawa film. Note, though, that his dream-inspired work was not derived from lucid dreams, but instead from your typical dream.
dizzy wrote:You are correct in saying that you know your dreams, that I cannot doubt or argue with, but you know not the dreams of me or any other so a passage like the one above is based entirely on speculation pertaining to what others may dream and therefore holds no wait in any argument or in this case open discussion.
I'm not so sure about this. Let me try to give an example.
Let's say I break my leg. As a result, I proclaim that "breaking a leg is painful". If we take your above logic, it would follow that breaking a leg is only painful
for me. But we all know better. Unless you have a terribly rare disease which makes it impossible for you to feel pain, breaking a leg will, indeed, be painful.
I'm not saying that experiences are not subjective, but there are some universal aspects to experiences, as well.
dizzy wrote:Both what is seen as the dream state and waking state are states all the same and unless you are of a higher intelligence, and if you are I will apologise now, you do not know.
Sure, waking life and the dream are human experiences. Make the best of both. But, in my experience, the ability of lucid dreaming does not make dreams, generally speaking, any more enjoyable nor less frightening. Instead, that's part of the problem: with lucid dreaming, you can make dreams enjoyable enough so that, at times, you would rather sleep 12 hours than sleep as needed for good health. Also, with lucid dreaming, you will find that instead of the typical nightmare, what you have is something closer to a nightmarish acid trip.
dizzy wrote:How about giving your tips on how to get to and remain in the lucid state and we will let everyone else decide on whether the dream world has any value or significance and they can experience it for themselves and take what they will without just going on what you say it is and what it isn't.
Eh, you can find the tips I have all over the place. If someone really wants to know, they can find the information on their own. Like I said, I do not advise, nor do I see any real value in, lucid dreaming. Therefore, I would feel irresponsible were I to hand out the tips you request.
dizzy wrote:Im sorry if I seem a tad harsh but come on we are talking about dreams here.
No problem, friend.
Let's just not confuse dreaming with the notion of dreams as synonymous with ambitions, hopes and goals.I have nothing against the later three.