@Steve 41oo,
Steve 41oo wrote:
Advocate wrote:
No matter what Israel does or doesn't do in defending itself, its enemies deem it to be guilty of something..
because its true
With respect, Steve, that reply involves a logical fallacy listed in the Principia Mathematica under the heading "The Golden Mountain does not Exist"; it consists of adopting a hypothetical phoneme, term, or datum (e.g. the article "the" or the verb "defending" in these 2 examples) on to the syllogism proving that they are wrong.
Correct would be that "defence" (well, defense as spelled here, but the issue is logic not spelling) constitutes appallingly Orwellian newspeak at its worst in this case, and that "the" cannot be logically shown to meet the Scottish jury's option "not proven!" but that "a" can, and does. It's a matter of esoteric number theory, with which I'd never bother an engineer