Diest TKO wrote:snood wrote:Diest TKO wrote:Thank you snood. Just a thought. You are in the military, how do you feel about African Americans in leadership roles? I know the Navy has come out and said that they don't feel like they've done more talking than action on diversifying the ranks.
Thoughts?
K
O
Not sure exactly what you're asking - It's sort of a broad question.
But I'll give a shot at an answer.
I "feel" like there is a wide spectrum of competency represented among blacks just as among any other group. There are people who are black who seem born to take charge and to whom people gravitate, and who lead with firmness and fairness. I've known a few. At the other end there are spineless idiots who are black that I wouldn't want to follow to the office water cooler, much less under arms into a hostile area. I've known some of them too.
Sorry, I didn't realize how vague my question was. I started to ask one question and then changed mid sentence I believe.
What I meant to ask is, do you think that black officers are under greater scrutiny than others because of sentiments like the one voiced by your SGT T? Like, do you think a promotion comes with the added pressure to not "**** this up for all the other black soldiers."
T
K
O
The whole idea of race and vested authority in the eyes of people of the same race, and those of other races, is a slippery concept fraught with footholds for ill-advised assumptions and demagoguing. But since I brought it up, I will try to answer...
I can only speak for myself, and I don't want to feed the trolls who are always on the lookout for any opportunity to accuse someone of hypersensitivity on matters of race. But I am always aware of it when I am in the presence of any black person of field grade rank (in the Army, that is a Major or higher). For one thing, black Majors and higher than Major are not that common in my experience. They're not unheard of, but just not common.
For another thing (and to try to answer your revised question), I believe that high ranking blacks are very much under a certain kind of scrutiny by other blacks (not to mention a double standard from the system that makes them work harder to achieve, in my opinion). I think some of that scrutiny by blacks is a hope that they will do well, not bollocks things up and make "us" look bad. Some of the scrutiny by whites is - well, let's put it this way: Have you ever seen any white US senator have his patriotism questioned or be treated as if he had gone beyond his station in life to dare think he might be president - the way Obama has?
Well, I think higher ranking blacks get some of that scrutiny, too.