CalamityJane wrote:I think most of us cannot comprehend how different black people are
perceived and treated in situations that are quite normal to us (meaning
whites).
A routine traffic job does create anxiety in all of us, but the treatment
a white man receives from an officer will be quite different than a black
man receives, and we all have seen some of the mishandling.
Just the other day I saw a video on CNN where a black youth in custody was smashed against the wall by a white police officer. That was in Kalamazoo.
You don't hear of this kind of mistreatment given to white youth.
In part because the media is not as sensitive to it as when it happens to black youths, and in part because you're probably not listening for it.
If you think brutal cops only pick on black kids, you're mistaken. Smart mouth white kids get similar treatment.
I had a couple of run ins with cops when I was in my late teens.
Once because my two friends and I were playing golf with only two sets of clubs and we happened to be in front of (as we eventually learned) a detective and his wife/girlfriend/mistress and were slowing them down. On the 15th green, while putting out, a beautifully struck ball fell in between us. The guy was good, but not that good and so the ball could have easily hit one of us. My friend turned to the guy driving up in his cart and gave him the single digit salute. The next thing we know he's flashing a badge, smacking us around and pulling his gun. I guess he figured it would impress his companion. Fortunately as one friend approached him from behind with a raised club, and I began to have visions of the next day's headlines in the local paper:
Drug crazed hippies attack detective on golf course; quick acting law officer plugs all three, the clown must have realized what sort of sh*t he had gotten himself into and fell back apologizing.
The second episode was during a march in NYC in 1970 protesting the Vietnam War and more specifically the shootings at Kent State. This was somewhat infamous for the fact that NYC construction workers attacked some of the protesters. At the time, (and perhaps now) I would like to say I was at the forefront of the march and while battling Hard Hats, got set upon by the Pigs. Nope --- although I was away from the main hubbub, someone did something stupid as respects the police lining the streets (I still don't know what it was) and the next thing I knew cops with flailing batons were all over the place. One of them found me and opened a six stitch gash in my head.. This was well before teevo and so I had to rely upon friends watching the TV, but my little tussle, apparently never made the news. Maybe if I had died it would.
The point is that cops are humans and some of them are assh*les and some may overreact in an adrenaline charged situation. Either way, whether or not they have an innate hatred for blacks , they can be relied upon to occassionally rough up browns, yellows, reds and even whites.
The fact of the matter is that blacks are disproportionatly responsible for crimes and therefore, it logically follows, subject to greater interaction with police.
Irrespective of what the sociological roots of this fact may be, it is a fact.
As much as we might like to believe that our law enforcement officers are capable of being utterly objective and above prejudice (which I hasten to add is not synonymous with hating blacks), it is foolish to expect the same.
If a certain percentage of cops are going to be brutal jackassess then their misdeeds are bound to be more evident as respects a group with which they most often come in contact, and which attract enhanced media attention.
Any substance to allegations that police profile by race requires statistics that go beyond the number of interactions between police and a given race. There may very well be such statistics out there, but here in Texas (which I know y'all Liberals consider to be the third circle of Hell) when I drive by a traffic stop and notice the driver is black or hispanic the vehicle is almost never a clean, late model car.
Since drug-dealers and otherwise successful criminals are more likely to be driving an expensive, late model vehicle (irrespective of race) any assumption drawn from this anecdotal evidence needs to be that the police profile based on class. A different issue altogether.
C-Jane wrote:Like eoe, I also think that in neighborhoods where ethnic minorities live, schools are in desperate needs of good teachers and good programs. The better educated the kids are, the greater their chances to succeed in life.
Perhaps, but then why hasn't it happened? It certainly isn't because only you and eoe have come to this brilliant conclusion?
Regurgitating this as a "need," so many, many years after it was originally identified is on the one hand utterly vapid, and on the other, an indictment of our public school system.
Are we going to extend the foul influence of racism to "good teachers" not wanting to devote their skills to minorities?
Alternative possibilities:
Good Teachers are not altruistic saints who should be expected to do more than most of the rest of us in addressing these social problems simply because they can. Teacher Unions that enforce mediocrity in our public school system are not about to allow the rest of us to incent the Good Teachers, through exceptional compensation, towards the toughest jobs.
Why should Good Teachers be required to focus their skills on Bad Students? Why shouldn't Society want the Best Teachers to focus on the Best Students?
If we accept that Society will always have classes (and I acknowledge that many will not find this axiomatic), isn't it in the best interests of Society to find ways to maximize the contributions of the Good Student than to bring the Bad Student a bit closer to the mean?
The answer is that given the right pressure, we will all agree that this is the case. Case in point: When gas was below $3.00 a gallon, Americans could feel magnanimous about the "pristine" stretches of Alaska and 100 miles off our coast. Now that it is averaging above $4.00, look how Americans want more drilling everywhere.
It is actually remarkable testimony to America that huge segments of our population feel so confident about our future that they demand counter-intuitive focuses on, by the standards of the rest of the world, marginal problems.
C-Jane wrote:On a side note: my 12 year old daughter has a new friend who came over to the house last Saturday. When I opened the door, I see a black
girl standing there and I was surprised, since my daughter had not mentioned at all that her friend is black. She sees her friend as someone
she likes to spend time with, and couldn't care less about the color of
her skin. It never occurred to her to mention this to me, as she is completely oblivious to that, and I like to keep it that way, color doesn't
matter.
If you and your daughter were in the mall one Saturday and she tried to point out this friend to you (before you met her), how long do you think it would take before she said "The black one?"
C-Jane wrote:Hopefully one day, we all can see the person before we see the color of their skin.
Well we just won't will we?
I meet a black person for the first time and I see his or her skin color before I "see" the person. Makes me a bigot? If so, then I am a "bigot" about other clearly obvious physical characteristics: hair color, weight, height, age, symetry of features, deformities etc etc etc. Arguing that we should not notice "differences" is arguing against a evolutionary surrvival technic that as served us quite well, and we are nowhere near the stage when we can be expected to separate ourselves from such tactics.
Advocating literal color-blindness is simply stupid. The measure of a person is whether or not, once past the legitimate and prelimnary reactions to physical characteristics, they are able to judge their neighbor based on character and not characteristics.
And so, yes we should hope and work for a society wherein the color of someone doesn't immediately conjure up prejudicial assumptions, but some of the burden of this task lies with the particular people of color.
It makes no sense for us to insist that color/race/class may not have a negative connotation when the first African-American candidate for President spends Father's Day lecturing black men on their responsibility to abide by social norms.