@Foxfyre,
Quote:
Give me hard evidence if you believe that. The states don't seem to be doing so good and most Americans disagree with you.
Most Americans don't know a single thing about our government or the economy, so I don't find that stat to be very compelling. However -
http://blog.prospect.org/blog/weblog/DCEconClubprint.pdf
Quote:
The role of the Recovery Act is clearest in state and local spending. Sharp falls in revenues and balanced budget requirements have been forcing state and local governments to tighten their belts significantly. But, state and local government spending actually rose at a healthy 2.4% annual rate in the second quarter of 2009. This followed two consecutive quarters of decline, and was the highest growth rate in two years. No one can doubt that the $33 billion of state fiscal relief that has already gone out thanks to the Recovery Act is a key source of this increase.
There's pretty solid evidence that the stim bill has helped slow our decline significantly.
Quote:
You don't have hundreds of thousands more people filing unemployment claims every week when the economy is growing.
Well, that's probably b/c our economy isn't growing; but the rate of decline has slowed dramatically, and if we're not at a bottom, we are near it.
Quote:
Give me hard evidence for that. I don't recall it being done that way though I understand that's the spin the leftwing blogs are putting on it these days. I do recall that it received wide bipartisan support with members on both sides of the aisle arguing for its passage. There was genuine urgency at the time as we did not know yet what our enemy had in store for us and we knew we had to have ability to intercept any additional threats after 9/11.
The PATRIOT act was rushed through Congress and voted on by many who hadn't read it. All part of the fear-mongering the Republicans engaged in after 9/11.
You don't recall this many-thousands page document being rushed? Let's look at the legislative history, from Wikipedia:
Quote: * Introduced in the House of Representatives as H.R. 3162 by Frank James Sensenbrenner, Jr. on October 23, 2001
* Passed the House on October 24, 2001 (Yeas: 357; Nays: 66)
* Passed the Senate on October 25, 2001 (Yeas: 98; Nays: 1)
* Signed into law by President Bush on October 26, 2001
The legislation was introduced three days before Bush signed it. This is the ultimate example of legislation which was rushed; and it was done so intentionally, in the same way that you are now accusing Obama and the Dems of rushing things - but to an infinitely greater degree.
Cycloptichorn