soz quotes kamiya...
Quote:In effect, Steinem was arguing that sexism trumps racism as a national concern and backing that up by claiming that women in America have fewer options than black men. But this claim is flawed,
That's of course not what she said but is rather a statement of what Kamiya thinks might be an accurate nutshell description of her 'thesis'.
The problem with Kamiya's piece here is a small but important one because he reaches for a simple either/or frame of reference. We don't have to decide or argue who has the worse of it, women or people of color, in an over-arching evaluation (not so easy to do in any case). More appropriately, we need to try and understand how either group have been and are being marginalized as regards power. While rates of black male incarceration tell us an undeniable story about racism, so the rates of spousal beatings or relative ratios of women in high office tells us something about the other problem.
We can speculate as to where and when one problem trumps the other. I did this earlier in a post where I suggested what was a new idea to me, that sexism
might be a more intractable problem in achieving high office than color. The idea arose as a consequence of observing all those gender matters I've talked about earlier, as I've perceived or interpreted them. They didn't arise in my noggin because I'm a Hillary supporter.
In this limited sphere, it may well be that my perception is accurate. Or it might be that I have it wrong. But it is not discountable in the manner that kamiya attempts.