@Setanta,
Setanta wrote:As i've alreay pointed out, this is neither an inferior or a superior system, it's just a different system.
I like less restricted systems better, and I suspect so do dlowan and others in this thread. Since I didn't say anything about "superior" or "inferior" in any objective sense, I'm going to leave it at that.
Setanta wrote:It may well be that "permissiveness" is greater in Gemany. But so what?
So Germany is a natural experiment by which we can gage the pressure of advertisers against swearing, in a setting where such pressure would make a difference. No difference is observable between private channels, who get
all of their revenue from advertising, and public channels, who get
a little of their revenue from advertising. We can therefore conclude that advertisers' pressure against profanity is negligible. That's the only reason I brought up Germany.
Setanta wrote:My overall complaint, though, is the constant niggling drum beat of criticisms, all of which seem to be predicated on a condescending attitude toward these differences.
Complain away. Personally, though, I find nothing condescending about saying things like "the US healthcare system sucks compared to Canada's", or "German coffee sucks compared to Italian coffee"---or "US TV censorship sucks compared to Australia's, Britain's, and Germany's". Indeed I would be surprised if you had never made comparisons of this type between the countries you've traveled and lived in.