1
   

Any serious Christians left?

 
 
timberlandko
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 10:42 am
That horse sure looks dead to me - prolly oughtta quit hitting it; seems the horse don't care, and besides, you're just agitating the flies.
0 Replies
 
Intrepid
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 11:19 am
maporche wrote:

Quote:
When I refer to Arella May below, I am referencing Christians in general
Arella Mae knows the only true word of god.
Arella Mae knows that 4.5 billion people will burn in hell (or whatever).
Arella Mae knows that she will not burn in hell.
Arella Mae knows that every other religion is false.
Arella Mae knows that her morals are better than mine (her's come from god, who is apparently perfect)
Arella Mae knows that I was born a bad person, and continue to be a bad person (original sin, and subsequent sins).


I will not post on this particular topic after I say this. Since you indicate that you are referencing "Christians in general" with your reply, you have included me and several others.

I can absolutely say that your summation does not apply to me, as a Christian, and probably many, many Christians.

There is no way for us to know that we will go to heaven until we either arrive or don't

There is absolutely no way for us to know who will and won't go to heaven.

There is absolutely no way we can know if our morals are any different or better than anybody elses. Christian or non.

We were ALL born with original sin. Therefore, we started out exactly like you did.


bleh, bleh, bleh..... That's All Folks
0 Replies
 
Phoenix32890
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 11:58 am
Man, do I hate "painting with a broad brush". That is why groups around the world are killing each other. Over and over again, it's "us and them".

Maporche, I really don't care what you believe. But lumping people together into one foul mass is the infection that is rotting the world. What I call the "tribal mentality" is causing more grief and havoc, and may be the force that eventually destroys this world.

Isn't it far better to get to know people, one on one, with their beliefs, idiosyncracies, habits and peculiarities, without making a blanket judgement about groups?

I think that if you look hard enough, you can find that human beings have more in common than differences, if a person would only care to see beyond the superficials.
0 Replies
 
Arella Mae
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 12:13 pm
maporsche wrote:
Arella Mae wrote:
maporsche wrote:
Intrepid wrote:
The problem seems to be a vindictiveness against AM by maporsche. maporsche has admitted to what has been said, but still insists that AM has an agenda different that anyone else.

I am not sure whether the word superior should be used, but each would certainly think that they are right. Why can't it just be left at that?


I've left it at that. I was just responding to RL, who apparently didn't read the entire thread.


maporsche, you have not left it. You still insist that I feel other than I do. I accept you feel as you have said you feel. Why can't you accept that I feel as I feel? I am honestly asking you this because I really do not undertand why you don't accept what I am telling you when they are my thoughts and feelings.



I guess I don't accept what you are saying to be true, because I am apparently unable to understand how your beliefs don't go hand in hand with a feeling of superiority. Allow me to explain why I think that:

You say you have the understanding of the Ultimate Truth. That Ultimate Truth is the god of the bible. You and the followers of the Theory of Christianity claim to have the truth over 4.5 billion other people. You may say that the bible makes this claim, but you have indeed chosen to believe in the bible, so it is your claim as well. Everyone but the believers of your religion will burn in hell, or be without god's presence, or whatever your sect of the Theory of Christianity believes. So to recap.

When I refer to Arella May below, I am referencing Christians in general
Arella Mae knows the only true word of god.
Arella Mae knows that 4.5 billion people will burn in hell (or whatever).
Arella Mae knows that she will not burn in hell.
Arella Mae knows that every other religion is false.
Arella Mae knows that her morals are better than mine (her's come from god, who is apparently perfect)
Arella Mae knows that I was born a bad person, and continue to be a bad person (original sin, and subsequent sins).


These are pretty superior sounding statement, if not superior than at least give me arrogant.

So, Arella Mae, while you may indeed hold on that you don't feel superior, I will continue to believe that you do at least on some level of your psyche, simply because I cannot comprehend how the arrogance of your chosen religion does not automatically come with a superoity complex. I don't think you are lying to all of us, but I do think you are lying to yourself.

I will leave it at that if you like and if you choose we don't have to discuss it any further, but I don't think we'll ever agree.


Actually, maporsche I am glad that I asked because there seems to be a lot more to it than I was gathering from what you posted. So, let me try to address each of the above statements. However, the one thing I think you need to NOT do is generalize. That, I believe, is a big problem with religion and a lot of other things in the world today. Things, people, situations, etc., need to be taken on their own face value and not based on generalities. So, with that said, that is how I will address these: from MY OWN PERSONAL standpoint (caps for emphasis only):

Quote:
Arella Mae knows the only true word of god.


First of all, I don't believe I ever claimed this. What I have stated is I don't think anyone (person, religion, etc.) has 100% of the 100% truth. I can only tell you that what I do understand I do understand it to be truth, but I am willing to be taught and if I am in error over something and it is pointed out to me I can adjust my thinking.

Quote:
Arella Mae knows that 4.5 billion people will burn in hell (or whatever).


I really get the impression from some that they think Christians run around all day thinking to ourselves, "Oh that one is going to hell or that one is going to heaven." This is so not the case. Do I consciously think about that? It may be a fleeting thought when someone says they don't accept Jesus as the Saviour but I say a prayer about it and give it to God. If they want to discuss it fine then we do. If they don't, well, then it's forgotten and left in God's hands.

Quote:
Arella Mae knows that she will not burn in hell.


I cannot deny that statement because that is what I am promised in the Bible. However, it still doesn't make me superior to you or anyone else on the face of the planet. I made the choice that was right for ME.

Quote:
Arella Mae knows that every other religion is false.


I don't believe I have ever said that. Not one time. I am one that believes that there will be people saved from all denominations (much to the chagrin of some Christians I know, believe me). Now, if they don't have Jesus Christ as their Saviour, then yes, I do consider them false religions (Muslim, Buddhists, etc.). According to the Bible, that is what they are. And I would imagine that those in those religions believe my religion is false? So? That's what they believe and it has no effect on my life.

Quote:
Arella Mae knows that her morals are better than mine (her's come from god, who is apparently perfect)


I don't believe I said that either maporsche. We may have different morals but I don't recall saying mine were better than yours or anyone else's. That's not my place nor within my authority to decide that. God makes those decisions, not me. Now, it's true I decide who I want to associate with and their morals are surely part of that decision, just as I imagine it would be with you? If you decide not to associate with someone because of something you don't like about them or their life, do you consider yourself superior to them?

Quote:
Arella Mae knows that I was born a bad person, and continue to be a bad person (original sin, and subsequent sins).


I do? How the heck do I know that? I don't even know you, maporsche. All I know of you is what you post on this forum. How could I ever make that decision, if I would? We all sin maporsche. For ALL have sinned....seems to me that makes us equal.

I really do appreciate you taking the time to spell all that out for me because it really did make me wonder why, even though I told you I didn't, you still thought I felt that way. I hope that this will help you understand a bit more why I don't feel superior to you or anyone else. Do I think I chose the right way? Of course I do otherwise I wouldn't have chosen it. But is it superior? No, it's just different than yours.

Thanx again. Laughing
0 Replies
 
dyslexia
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 12:24 pm
You too can join The Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Dead Horses.
Please sign up soon.
0 Replies
 
Arella Mae
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 12:49 pm
For pete's sake! We aren't arguing here. I asked maporsche a question to try to better understand the situation and he/she was kind enough to give me an honest answer. So please, just butt out! Razz

So maporsche, I will just wait for your response. Laughing
0 Replies
 
maporsche
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 01:29 pm
Intrepid wrote:
maporche wrote:

Quote:
When I refer to Arella May below, I am referencing Christians in general
Arella Mae knows the only true word of god.
Arella Mae knows that 4.5 billion people will burn in hell (or whatever).
Arella Mae knows that she will not burn in hell.
Arella Mae knows that every other religion is false.
Arella Mae knows that her morals are better than mine (her's come from god, who is apparently perfect)
Arella Mae knows that I was born a bad person, and continue to be a bad person (original sin, and subsequent sins).


I will not post on this particular topic after I say this. Since you indicate that you are referencing "Christians in general" with your reply, you have included me and several others.

I can absolutely say that your summation does not apply to me, as a Christian, and probably many, many Christians.

There is no way for us to know that we will go to heaven until we either arrive or don't.

There is absolutely no way for us to know who will and won't go to heaven.

But you do know that there is no way that I will go to heaven because I do not accept JC as my savior, RIGHT? Your bible says this is true.

There is absolutely no way we can know if our morals are any different or better than anybody elses. Christian or non.

Your bible tells you what is morally true. The ultimate moral truth as told by your god. Assuming that my morals are different than those that god has dictated to you, then is it possible that my morals are more true than gods? If you believe that the morals as told in the bible are true, and are god's word, and I can assure you that my morals are different than the bibles, is there any possibility that my morals are better or more true than gods?

We were ALL born with original sin. Therefore, we started out exactly like you did.

I was not born a bad person or with sin. You, or Christians, are telling me that I was.

bleh, bleh, bleh..... That's All Folks
0 Replies
 
maporsche
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 01:49 pm
Arella Mae wrote:

Actually, maporsche I am glad that I asked because there seems to be a lot more to it than I was gathering from what you posted. So, let me try to address each of the above statements. However, the one thing I think you need to NOT do is generalize. That, I believe, is a big problem with religion and a lot of other things in the world today. Things, people, situations, etc., need to be taken on their own face value and not based on generalities. So, with that said, that is how I will address these: from MY OWN PERSONAL standpoint (caps for emphasis only):


I do not think that I am generalizing (I'm not sure why I used that word), but from what I understand what I have posted are the beliefs of Cristians.

Quote:

Quote:
Arella Mae knows the only true word of god.


First of all, I don't believe I ever claimed this. What I have stated is I don't think anyone (person, religion, etc.) has 100% of the 100% truth. I can only tell you that what I do understand I do understand it to be truth, but I am willing to be taught and if I am in error over something and it is pointed out to me I can adjust my thinking.


Isn't the bible the only true word of god. If you believe the bible to be true, then you know the only true word of god, unless the bible is wrong....

Quote:

Quote:
Arella Mae knows that 4.5 billion people will burn in hell (or whatever).


I really get the impression from some that they think Christians run around all day thinking to ourselves, "Oh that one is going to hell or that one is going to heaven." This is so not the case. Do I consciously think about that? It may be a fleeting thought when someone says they don't accept Jesus as the Saviour but I say a prayer about it and give it to God. If they want to discuss it fine then we do. If they don't, well, then it's forgotten and left in God's hands.


If they don't accept Jesus, then they go to hell. It's stated plain as day in the bible. So whether or not you 'run around all day thinking' about it is besides the point. Your bible says that 4.5 billion people will burn in hell. If you beleive your bible to be true, then you know that 4.5 billion people will burn in hell.


Quote:

Quote:
Arella Mae knows that she will not burn in hell.


I cannot deny that statement because that is what I am promised in the Bible. However, it still doesn't make me superior to you or anyone else on the face of the planet. I made the choice that was right for ME.


We agree. Except, that according to your bible, you made the choice that is right for EVERYONE. If the only way to go to heaven is through Jesus, then it's not a choice that is just right for you. You think that EVERYONE should believe in Jesus to get to heaven, because your bible tells you that is true. The bible, and subsequently yourself, knows that the right answer is salvation through Jesus Christ for ALL people, not just you.

Quote:

Quote:
Arella Mae knows that every other religion is false.


I don't believe I have ever said that. Not one time. I am one that believes that there will be people saved from all denominations (much to the chagrin of some Christians I know, believe me). Now, if they don't have Jesus Christ as their Saviour, then yes, I do consider them false religions (Muslim, Buddhists, etc.). According to the Bible, that is what they are. And I would imagine that those in those religions believe my religion is false? So? That's what they believe and it has no effect on my life.


I never said you said it exactly, I was reference Christianity, and I used your name to illustrate that point.

But, because this is what is told in the bible, of course you believe it. I'm also not talking about different demoninations. The 4.5 billion people I reference as non-Christians.

So, my point stands. You believe all other religions besides Christianity to be false.

Quote:

Quote:
Arella Mae knows that her morals are better than mine (her's come from god, who is apparently perfect)


I don't believe I said that either maporsche. We may have different morals but I don't recall saying mine were better than yours or anyone else's. That's not my place nor within my authority to decide that. God makes those decisions, not me. Now, it's true I decide who I want to associate with and their morals are surely part of that decision, just as I imagine it would be with you? If you decide not to associate with someone because of something you don't like about them or their life, do you consider yourself superior to them?



Again, I'm reference Christianity here. Your bible tells you that it's morals are superior and dictated from god. If my morals are different, then they are inferior by default.

Quote:

Quote:
Arella Mae knows that I was born a bad person, and continue to be a bad person (original sin, and subsequent sins).


I do? How the heck do I know that? I don't even know you, maporsche. All I know of you is what you post on this forum. How could I ever make that decision, if I would? We all sin maporsche. For ALL have sinned....seems to me that makes us equal.


If I sin I am a bad person right (did you watch the Kirk Cameron video I posted a while back, it says even a white lie is a hell-bound offense, and extremely displeasing to god). You know that I am a sinner by your morally-superior standpoint. You know I'm hell-bound.

We are equal based on your morally-superior position as told by the bible.


Quote:

I really do appreciate you taking the time to spell all that out for me because it really did make me wonder why, even though I told you I didn't, you still thought I felt that way. I hope that this will help you understand a bit more why I don't feel superior to you or anyone else. Do I think I chose the right way? Of course I do otherwise I wouldn't have chosen it. But is it superior? No, it's just different than yours.

Thanx again. Laughing


Fair enough. And I agree, we are not arguing anymore, simply discussing.
0 Replies
 
Arella Mae
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 05:02 pm
I give up. You don't accept that I feel the way that I feel so I'm done. Thank you for your time.
0 Replies
 
echi
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 05:29 pm
maporsche.

What is the deal? If you wanna pick a fight with some Christians, let me tell you, I'm all for it. I got your back. But I don't see any fight, here.

Generally speaking (of course), Christians believe they have made the best decision (superior, if you like). In no way does that necessarily mean that they regard themselves as being superior to non-Christians. In order for you to believe that, wouldn't you have to believe that Christians measure their self-worth exclusively by their decision making abilities?
0 Replies
 
maporsche
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 06:25 pm
Arella Mae wrote:
I give up. You don't accept that I feel the way that I feel so I'm done. Thank you for your time.


I accept that you feel the way you do. I just have a hard time understanding why, and like I said earler, I'll probably never understand it.

But so be it. I'm done too, it was fun while it lasted.
0 Replies
 
Arella Mae
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 06:28 pm
maporsche wrote:
Arella Mae wrote:
I give up. You don't accept that I feel the way that I feel so I'm done. Thank you for your time.


I accept that you feel the way you do. I just have a hard time understanding why, and like I said earler, I'll probably never understand it.

But so be it. I'm done too, it was fun while it lasted.


Well, I'd say there was progress made if you at least accept that is the way I feel. I wouldn't mind discussing this with you maporsche. Can you pin down exactly what part you don't understand? I know you told me the reasons you felt I didn't feel the way I do but now that you accept that part maybe we can pinpoint the other part? I'm willing to try if you are. Laughing
0 Replies
 
maporsche
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 06:31 pm
echi wrote:
maporsche.

What is the deal? If you wanna pick a fight with some Christians, let me tell you, I'm all for it. I got your back. But I don't see any fight, here.

Generally speaking (of course), Christians believe they have made the best decision (superior, if you like). In no way does that necessarily mean that they regard themselves as being superior to non-Christians. In order for you to believe that, wouldn't you have to believe that Christians measure their self-worth exclusively by their decision making abilities?


I'm not trying to fight, but I think I've made some pretty strong points that the Christian positions on life after death and morality strongly imply a feeling of superiority or at the very least extreme arrogance.

I also believe that many Chrisitans will disagree with me, but their disagreement does not make me wrong.

And as far as measuring their self-worth on their decision making abilities I would refer you to a specific comment that AM made about things being decided by the god of the bible, or saying something like 'god made the rules'. I think many Christian's will push that responsibility to god and trust in god's judgement.......and they will ignore the fact that they CHOSE the believe in the god of the bible.
0 Replies
 
Intrepid
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 06:56 pm
maporsche wrote:
echi wrote:
maporsche.

What is the deal? If you wanna pick a fight with some Christians, let me tell you, I'm all for it. I got your back. But I don't see any fight, here.

Generally speaking (of course), Christians believe they have made the best decision (superior, if you like). In no way does that necessarily mean that they regard themselves as being superior to non-Christians. In order for you to believe that, wouldn't you have to believe that Christians measure their self-worth exclusively by their decision making abilities?


I'm not trying to fight, but I think I've made some pretty strong points that the Christian positions on life after death and morality strongly imply a feeling of superiority or at the very least extreme arrogance.

I also believe that many Chrisitans will disagree with me, but their disagreement does not make me wrong.

And as far as measuring their self-worth on their decision making abilities I would refer you to a specific comment that AM made about things being decided by the god of the bible, or saying something like 'god made the rules'. I think many Christian's will push that responsibility to god and trust in god's judgement.......and they will ignore the fact that they CHOSE the believe in the god of the bible.


Strong points or no, there is no implication proven that Christians feel a superiority or arrogance. Would it not follow that atheists would have a feeling of superiority and arrogance based on what they believe? Wouldn't that be able to be argued by Christians? Of course it could. But I do not see this happening.

Christian disagreement with you does not make you wrong, as you say. However, your disagreement with the Christian position also does not make you right.

Personally, I can say that I choose to believe what I believe. Sure, there is a possibility that I could be wrong on God's plan. It may not even include me. However, I have chosen to believe and the actions or words of others will not make me waver from my position.

At the same time, I am not and never have tried to force my beliefs on anyone else. I will discuss, and yes even defend, my faith. I will not force it upon anyone else. The choice is up to each of us.

Also, I know for a fact that I do not believe as all Christians believe. If we all believed the same, we would not have so many different denominations.

Having a faith in God and Jesus Christ does not make us superior to anybody else and it does not make us special. Hopefully it is special to God, but we have no control over this other than living our lives as best we can in accordance with His will. Many will not understand this and though we may pray for them, we have no right to condemn them. They, like us, have made a choice.

Also, we are not perfect and without sin. We still need Godly grace and forgiveness of sin. That is not to say that we sin; receive forgiveness and continue sinning. Forgiveness requires a definite remorse and acknowledgement for the sin. A decided endeavour to improve is required. It is a constant inner battle.

We are also not without feelings and emotions. These are sometimes stretched to the limit in our defence of our religion and sometimes they get out of control. It is at these times that we are the most vulnerable to hearing the words...."You call yourself a Christian?"

If you think being a Christian is easy. Try it sometime.
0 Replies
 
Arella Mae
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 07:03 pm
Quote:
I'm not trying to fight, but I think I've made some pretty strong points that the Christian positions on life after death and morality strongly imply a feeling of superiority or at the very least extreme arrogance.


Well, I certainly don't consider the discussion we are having now a fight so we're squre there. I won't deny that yes, you have made some strong arguments here in favor of your view. I know plenty of Christians that do have that superior feeling and I even know some (some Calvinists) that actually think it's ok to laugh at someone they think isn't going to be saved because they feel God didn't choose that unsaved person. It's just something that needs to be looked at on an individual basis and not lumping all in there.

Quote:
I also believe that many Chrisitans will disagree with me, but their disagreement does not make me wrong.


Nope, sure doesn't. Like I said, I know plenty that you would be right on with this.

Quote:
And as far as measuring their self-worth on their decision making abilities I would refer you to a specific comment that AM made about things being decided by the god of the bible, or saying something like 'god made the rules'. I think many Christian's will push that responsibility to god and trust in god's judgement.......and they will ignore the fact that they CHOSE the believe in the god of the bible.


Hmm, now in some instances yes I can agree with you. One type of instance in particular is this: Don't know if you've heard it or not but (I'll have to find the scripture) no one comes to God unless He draws them (totally paraphrased). Well, I have seen people use that very scripture as an excuse for someone turning from God because of the behavior of someone witnessing to them. The person witnessing would be sitting there screaming at the other person telling them how wicked they were, etc., and the only thing it did was tick the other person off, with much justification I might add! When this situation was brought up to them, they merely stated, "No one comes to God unless He draws them." I was like Shocked ! How do you know God didn't draw them to you so that you could tell them about Jesus?

Does God draws us to Him? Yes, He sure does. But then we have a responsibility. We can either tell and show someone in love what Jesus is about or we can go "well, you're just going to hell anyway so there!". And yet, some of these very same Christians will tell you that you can cause another Christian to stumble (sin). Seems a bit of a double standard to me. If you can cause someone to sin then why can't you cause them to turn from God? So, I think I understand a little of how you feel on this. They just turn around and blame their own behavior on God just like you said some do.


Intrepid,

Beautifully put
.http://us.i1.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/i/mesg/emoticons7/41.gif
0 Replies
 
maporsche
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 08:00 pm
Maybe we remove the 'feeling' out of the question. Let's no longer discuss whether or not you feel superior, but instead try to determine if you are superior.

Based on your beliefs, assuming they are true as told in the bible.

Is heaven preferable to hell?
Is heaven for all mankind who choose to accept Jesus?
Is the bible the ONLY word of God?
By following the bible's teachings, confessing your sins, and accepting Jesus Christ will you go to heaven?
Will other religions who do not accept Jesus Christ, or those who accept no religion go to hell (or whatever you believe instead of hell)?
Are the morals in the bible the direct word of God?

Acting under the assumption that all of these things are true as told in the bible I would admit that those who accept Christ and Christianity are superior to those who have not. One of the definations of superior is "higher in place or position" and it is indisputable that if the bible is the truth then those who believe in the bible and follow it are higher on the list to go to heaven, or they are in a better position to get there.

If your beliefs are true. You are indeed superior to me.
0 Replies
 
Intrepid
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 08:11 pm
Believe what you want, maporsche. I am through with your childish rantings. You have received anwers, but you continue to push for something else. You also continue to move from one thing to another and expect something that you never seem to believe.

I am very annoyed that you state "Based on your beliefs, assuming they are true " Are you infering a lie? I am beginning to think that maybe I am superior to you.... not in the spiritual sense, but in the earthly sense. You don't seem to know when to quit. I am also beginning to think that you have a sense of inferiority and that is why you are so fixed on this item of superiority. Chill.
0 Replies
 
snood
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 09:47 pm
Intrepid:
Quote:
I am also beginning to think that you have a sense of inferiority and that is why you are so fixed on this item of superiority.


Yup. Big as day.
0 Replies
 
echi
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 10:46 pm
maporsche,

This is a strange hunt you're on (also strangely entertaining, I admit).

I actually think you may be getting somewhere, now. According to the belief, God does seem to consider them superior, and I can't imagine anyone arguing with God.
0 Replies
 
Arella Mae
 
  1  
Reply Fri 27 Oct, 2006 11:11 pm
Maporsche,

Just as with the decision to accept Jesus Christ as your Saviour or not is personal, I would think that this "superior" thing you got going on is also just that, personal. If you feel that way, then you do. If I don't feel that way, then I don't. Laughing
0 Replies
 
 

Related Topics

700 Inconsistencies in the Bible - Discussion by onevoice
Why do we deliberately fool ourselves? - Discussion by coincidence
Spirituality - Question by Miller
Oneness vs. Trinity - Discussion by Arella Mae
give you chills - Discussion by Bartikus
Evidence for Evolution! - Discussion by Bartikus
Evidence of God! - Discussion by Bartikus
One World Order?! - Discussion by Bartikus
God loves us all....!? - Discussion by Bartikus
The Preambles to Our States - Discussion by Charli
 
Copyright © 2025 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 0.03 seconds on 01/19/2025 at 12:37:58