Gelisgesti wrote:Hi Terry, wouldn't birth qualify as thoughtless and without identity?
Yes.
Quote:Your argument supports my point of view. If there is an afterlife you will be able to keep all the "wonderful things I have yet to experience in this life" .... if there is only death ....
If there is an afterlife and I choose to live out this life first, I will still have eternity to experience more things. If I were to cut this life short I would lose out on experiences, but wouldn't be around to know that I had missed anything.
OK, my premature death would have no effect on the "me" that no longer existed, but I would have lost many opportunities to make an impact on the world and the lives of other people. This is the only kind of immortality that I can truly count on.
Quote:I can accept that .... of course that begs the question of 'what is the form and function of the mind'?
Mind/soul are the same and can not exist outside the brain, which places them inside the physical body. Is their composition then considered flesh and bone? If other please explaine
The function of the mind is to consciously experience life and make choices. The form is still a bit of a mystery. Perhaps it is a 4-D virtual projection from the biochemical patterns created by neurons? (sounds good, doesn't it? Of course I just made that up. :wink: )
Quote:I would think that blonde hair and blue eyes or the deep pigmentation of a black person would entail a great deal of specificity.
Not really. Creating brain structure is far more involved than simply changing the amount of pigment.
Quote:If my clone takes twice the amount of music lessons and has a more acute sense of hearing, then what?
The area devoted to hearing in his brain is larger than yours, and his musical abilities are greater. He may choose a career as a musician. In any case, he is not identical to you in this respect.