Re: Definitions: Invent, Discover, Contrive, & Instinct
BumbleBeeBoogie wrote:CodeBorg, the topic of my post was about INVENTIONS, not discovering, contriving, or instinct.
D'oh, did I just go off again? Sorry, ummm checking:
Hoe ... electic light ... automobile ... meditation ... ego ... humans. Check, check, check, uh ...
4) The art of meditation is a pursuit, an attitude or field of study. The idea that one can create their own self-realization. An activity. An exercise or process. It was created at some point. A comparable thing might be: the field of genetics, the art of painting, the sport of golf. So I guess meditation is an INVENTION. But it's borderline. It might come down to semantics, whether one means a general practice, goal, or method.
5) Ego? An attitude or perspective on things. One particular form of reality or understanding. One form of logic processing. A state of mind, not in its static quality but in its patterns. Often associated with particular moods, but is not a mood. Ego is a way of being. A way of thinking. It's unconsciously taught, inherited, learned and assumed. A cultural tradition ... is evolved, developed, discovered, applied, but not really created. Like, to solve a problem.
Ego is a good tool for war. Or for acheivement. When it's deliberately cultivated. But like the use of chaos, or the use of anger or joy, it's usually a subconscious state of mind. Only sometimes deliberate.
Oh. You are very correct sir! A cultural tradition is not an invention unless it's deliberately engineered like Scientology or Christmas. Those are inventions, and while the IDEA or USE of ego is an invention, the ego itself is not. When looking for things that help humanity (as opposed to helping the world) then I should look for the creative thought process.
6) Humans? When plants breed humans for their ability to feed them, that's just one way of looking at a whole system of evolution. Plants and humans are interdependent and the process of breeding better farmers is a natural, involuntary pattern, accident, instinct, process.
We DISCOVER breeding and use our particular intelligence to DEVELOP a featherless chicken, or fungus-resistant strawberry, and that result is an INVENTION because of conscious intent by an individual. Domestic cats and dogs were not invented.
When plants' own form of intelligence develop a more suitable breed of farmer, their conscious intent exists but it's more mechanical and involuntary and spread across an entire population of plants working together, ... so a better human is not an INVENTION.
I think you're correct again!
:-D Excellent issues! :-D
1) Can something be invented unconsciously?
2) If it's the work of two people is it still invented? 100 people? A million?
3) Does an invention have to be a physical item, or can it be an idea, method, or approach? Is the number zero an invention? The whole idea of Love? Is a new field of study, like nanotechnology?
Sorry, but English isn't my first language, so sometimes the nuances pass me by. Thank you!