@Posh,
Both of your faces should be under the dictionary definition of mixed signals.
What is it you want from him?
All the texting and chatty Cathy stuff is likely to be coming across as flirting/playing hard to get with him.
If you want a relationship, say so. If you just want to be pals, then say so -- and tone down the flirty behavior, big time.
Oh, and next time? Download a GPS app on your phone if you don't already have one and call a taxi or an Uber.
This guy could have done pretty much anything to you-- yes, even after chatting with the cops. He is intrusive enough in your life to know who you visit.
If that's not triggering your red flag detector, then you need to recalibrate it.