revel wrote:I am glad that they filed a lawsuit, I am sure if they didn't think they stood a chance of pulling it off they wouldn't have done it ...
You should not discount the effort to gain political points as a partial motivation.
Quote:... and this way a lot of stuff that Fitzerold didn't disclose might be revealed in a civil lawsuit.
Hopefully so.
I'm very pleased they decided to file the lawsuit. I expect things to go very badly for the Wilsons.
And Lawrence O'Donnell, the leftist at Huffington Post, seems to agree:
Quote:OLBERMANN: Is winning even the point here? Would not the real victory, perhaps for the Wilson's, come simply in putting the White House on trial ?- quite literally having their day in court at the White House's expense?
O'DONNELL: I think winning better not be the point, because the one quick disagreement I have with John Dean is I think this is a very weak case. I wrote a book about a civil rights case, and I don't recognize any of the applications of civil rights law that they're using in this complaint. Bevins has entirely to do with law enforcement officials ?- guys with badges and guns. That's not what's involved here.
I think they're going to have a lot of trouble keeping this case in court. I think the vice president's side of the case has a very, very strong case in going for dismissal. [...]
It is a political piece of litigation, and you know that by reading the first paragraph of the complaint, Keith. This is not a legalistic document. The first paragraph quotes the first President Bush saying, in 1999, "We need more protection for the methods we use to gather intelligence and more protection for our sources ?- particularly our human sources, people that are risking their lives for their country." That's what Joe Wilson and Valerie Plame want the country to think about. They want the country to think about what the first President Bush was thinking about when he was talking about the urgency and the importance with which we must attach to protecting the secrecy of CIA human resources, and that's really the point that they're trying to get across here.
And they're going to get smacked around during the discovery phase, if it gets that far down the road.