roger wrote:Okay, nimh, what to do. Remove sanctions on Cuba?
I don't know.
The reasoning somewhere on this thread that "free trade is the best way to help bring communism down" (or something) does sound appealing, in a way. Sanctions didnt really work on South Africa, and they certainly didnt work on Iraq. Whereas one could say that, for example, post-Franco Spain has been so exemplary peaceful and stable (barring the Basque country), compared to its pre-dictatorship past, because of the economic prosperity that came about in the 60s and 70s. Economic prosperity that came about when foreign investors pulled in there against the protest of those who expressed disgust at what came down to financial support for a brutal dictator, and in so doing modernized the country and as a result the Spaniards' mindsets and frames of reference.
On the other hand, it just doesn't feel right to allow dictators to profit, often personally, from fully-fledged trade relations. And one could also say that some dictators - Pinochet, Mobutu - lasted a lot longer than might have been necessary thanks to the leash of life foreign trade gave them.
That's the longest "I don't know" I've posted yet. An alternative to blanket sanctions are perhaps the attempts, recently pursued much more vigorously, to cut ruling dictatorial clans off from their financial sources and bank accounts abroad, while allowing overall trade to continue. Would be xtremely hard to implement, and the more dictatorial a country is, the harder it is to separate the two, and Cuba is pretty dictatorial in this regard, too. But then the current sanctions should be easily circumvented too.