@Baldimo,
Quote:It wasn't neutral, it was favorable towards the Communists, it goes with your constant use of comrade towards people who don't support communism.
Um, this is the question I asked, comrade:
I wrote:How is the situation in Hong Kong going to end?
How do you interpret it as "being "favorable toward the Communists?"
Quote:What else do you think the plan is, to become slaves to communist China?
Since you had just said that they
didn't want to become political slaves of China, I let your own statement answer your own question. I don't know where you got the idea that anyone thinks they aren't seeking freedom from Beijing.
Quote:It's better to die fighting than live on your knees.
Kindergarten proverb from the Cold War. Better dead than red and all that. Simplistic fairy tales and shopworn slogans are a lousy substitute for thoughtful discussion. I can see why you prefer them.
Quote:They are working on it. Did you see the other day that students were starting to baricade some of the Universities?
And what exactly does barricading universities do to defeat the government? It prompts destructive reaction by the state, leading to more deaths.
Quote:No better way to fight a tyrannical govt then to arm the population.
And who is undertaking the job of arming the protestors? Dreaming about gunz in Colorado doesn't mean a thing on the ground in Hong Kong,
comrade.
Quote:This is why it's super important for the US to support HK.
Well what's holding us back?
Quote:They are still communists and have not turned their backs on it.
It's a one party state that inherited the "communist" name from the previous era (which wasn't a model of textbook communism either). It doesn't feature any of the well-known principles of Communism; it's strictly in business to make money.
Quote:If they stick to their path, they will get what they want if the rest of the world can continue expose what China is doing there, pressure could be brought to bear on China.
China isn't that susceptible to the sort of international pressure you dream about. Dictatorships seldom are, comrade.
Quote:
It isn't happening because the people of HK don't want that.
Nor does the Hong Kong government, nor does Beijing. That the the Hong Kong government might come to terms with the protestors and try to convince Beijing that the situation was under control wasn't my "recommendation"; I was simply posing a scenario that might have offered an alternative to a crackdown. It's not different from you imagining what the conflict would be like were the demonstrators armed.
Quote:You don't think fighting for freedom and liberty are worth the lives they will spend to gain what you have?
No, I
don't think one-sided confrontations between civilians and a powerful military resulting in death and martyrdom are worth the lives lost. If you think you can balance the loss of human life with the justness of a political cause you're delving into metaphysical speculation. The deaths at Tiananmen achieved nothing. Those martyrs have been erased from the history of China. They died in vain. Yet you're there, in comfort, egging on the protestors and suggesting they sacrifice their lives for something which won't be achieved by their dying for a hopeless cause. How noble.