willow_tl wrote:I am just waiting for the spin from the right...
I don't know if this qualifies as spin or not, but I don't have a problem with the statement, because I never believed it was all about finding WMDs from the start and I don't think the Bush Adminstration believed it was either.
I have written on several occasions that I fault the Administration for framing the invasion almost entirely in terms of WMD stockpiles.
First of all I believe they should have trusted the American public to be able to understand and appreciate the broader strategic and moral reasons for the invasion. They did not, and instead focused on the topic that could generate the best soundbites.
Secondly, they put all of their eggs in one basket (WMDs) and, as is often the case when this mistake is made, they lost almost all of their eggs when the basket fell.
Even if one believes George W Bush is an utter moron (a preposterous, but, sadly, prevalent opinion) surely you will agree that he is not surrounded by an entire bank of advisors who are all utter morons.
There was, no doubt, some manipulation of the intelligence in the sense of playing up some findings and downplaying others, but I find it impossible to believe that Bush, let alone his suspected puppeteers would invade Iraq almost solely on the basis of WMDs when they knew fairly clearly that no such WMDs existed.
Instead, I believe they really did believe that American troops were going to discover WMD stockpiles - hell, so did most of the world. I'm sure that no one was more agitated by the absence of WMDs than George Bush.
So, if one believes, as I do, that there were valid reasons to invade Iraq, beyond WMDs and that the Administration believed the same, then the failure to find WMDs does not mean the invasion was a failure.
Having put such a focus on WMDs, the Administration has placed itself in the tight spot in which it now resides. It wasn't necessary. They made a mistake, not in invading Iraq, but in the manner in which they developed the support of the American people. This lack of trust in the citizenry is disturbing and would factor more greatly in my voting decision this November if I thought the opposing candidate was worth consideration, but he is not.