@blatham,
blatham wrote:
Olivier5 wrote:Incrementalism is a belief system adopted by progressive people that are more afraid of change and happier with the status quo than they care to admit.
There's not a day that goes by where I don't scream at god for inventing language. "What a way to screw everything up, you jerk" is the complaint.
You're right. Let's clarify what we're talking about. I like to think of it in terms of appetite for risk (courage or at worse temerity) vs risk aversion (aka prudence or at worse cowardness). It stands to reason when we think in those terms that we all stand somewhere on a
gradiant of risk aversion -- appetite. So between the foolhardy revolutionary and an over-cautious incrementalist, there may exist quite a few shades of grey.
It also stands to reason that there is no "correct" shade here. In some situations prudence is advised, in others a little risk taking can be rewarded immensely.
In summary, it's not either incrementalist or revolutionary, it's a gradient, and there's no right or wrong answer, so who's to say that a prudent, baby-step approach to things is always the best one, in any and all circumstances?
Quote:As to incrementalism, one can observe that it is precisely how major social movements have advanced. [...] MLK wasn't stupid about this. Mandela wasn't either. Likewise, women's suffrage.
Mandela was clearly a revolutionary. MLK as well. He used non-violence to rapidely and radically solve an issue: segregation. Of course it didn't solve racism but that's not what he set out to do. Likewise for women suffrage, these girls were quite radical too in my view.
Quote:Calls for immediate change - the rejection of incrementalism - come from people of real passion and sincerity and, usually, good faith intentions. But this is also the sector of our populations from where the wild-eyed crazies tend to emerge. Neo-nazis aren't incrementalists.
The thing is, just because the enemy is for radical change in the wrong direction, doesn't disqualify radical change in the right direction.