[ See Annex below for the post of FBM. ]
FBM, you are asking about who or what created my God, I already explained to you that in my concept of God, He is the creator etc.
I think you did not get me, I already said and will repeat again, God is not in my concept in need of a cause or a creator.
You start from the point that God has a creator or cause, and I am telling you that in my concept God does not need a creator, etc., because He is in concept the creator and operator of the universe and of everything with a beginning.
We have to now discuss the validity of the concept of an uncreated or uncaused God, do you understand my request?
Here, tell me, as I have already said a thousand times, we must first determine the validity of a concept, before we go into determining the existence of the entity corresponding to the concept, of course after we have come to concurrence on the validity of the concept.
Now, tell me, what do you say about what is a valid concept?
Allow me to suggest what is to my stock knowledge a valid concept, namely:
A valid concept is first and foremost an idea that does not have any ingredients within its composition, which render the idea intrinsically self-contradictory.
For an example, the idea of a child with an IQ of a genius, that is a valid concept, because it does not have any ingredients that make the idea intrinsically self-contradictory.
An example of an invalid concept is the following:
The idea of a dictatorship government with genuine free election.
Now, do you understand what are valid concepts and what invalid concepts?
Please do not go on and on and on with your insistence of going on and on and on without any inkling at all of what is a valid concept and what an invalid concept.
This is one dodge of atheists, to seek refuge in the guise of not knowing; atheists even forbid themselves to think beyond the Big Bang.
Okay, tell me, if you have any idea at all of valid and invalid concepts, tell me your idea, and give examples, one each of a valid concept and one of an invalid concept.
Forgive me, if you don't even know what is a valid concept and an invalid concept, I have to avoid further interaction with you.
Who or what created your god? Alternatively, explain why your god is a special case that, unlike the rest of the universe, wasn't created. You keep accusing people of dodging, but you keep on dodging and dodging and dodging... Laughing
PS: If readers here notice that I am not replying anymore to a poster or posters here, it is because they are not into intelligent and respectful exchange of thoughts, but they are into malingering, in effect to sabotage communication among intelligent and respectful posters.