2
   

Army Stage managed Fall Hussein Statue

 
 
Reply Sat 3 Jul, 2004 06:48 pm
Army Stage-Managed Fall of Hussein Statue

Sat Jul 3, 7:55 AM ET Add Top Stories - Los Angeles Times to My Yahoo!


David Zucchino

The Army's internal study of the war in Iraq (news - web sites) criticizes some efforts by its own psychological operations units, but one spur-of-the-moment effort last year produced the most memorable image of the invasion.


• Latimes.com home page
• Subscribe to the Los Angeles Times



Latest headlines:
· Family of Marine Awaits Word of His Fate
AP - 1 hour, 7 minutes ago
· Draft Democratic platform calls for rebuilding alliances, skirts Iraq: report
AFP - 1 hour, 18 minutes ago
· Iraq Militants Claim Marine Beheading
AP - 1 hour, 27 minutes ago
Special Coverage





As the Iraqi regime was collapsing on April 9, 2003, Marines converged on Firdos Square in central Baghdad, site of an enormous statue of Saddam Hussein (news - web sites). It was a Marine colonel ?- not joyous Iraqi civilians, as was widely assumed from the TV images ?- who decided to topple the statue, the Army report said. And it was a quick-thinking Army psychological operations team that made it appear to be a spontaneous Iraqi undertaking.


After the colonel ?- who was not named in the report ?- selected the statue as a "target of opportunity," the psychological team used loudspeakers to encourage Iraqi civilians to assist, according to an account by a unit member.


But Marines had draped an American flag over the statue's face.


"God bless them, but we were thinking … that this was just bad news," the member of the psychological unit said. "We didn't want to look like an occupation force, and some of the Iraqis were saying, 'No, we want an Iraqi flag!' "


Someone produced an Iraqi flag, and a sergeant in the psychological operations unit quickly replaced the American flag.


Ultimately, a Marine recovery vehicle toppled the statue with a chain, but the effort appeared to be Iraqi-inspired because the psychological team had managed to pack the vehicle with cheering Iraqi children.


?- David Zucchino
  • Topic Stats
  • Top Replies
  • Link to this Topic
Type: Discussion • Score: 2 • Views: 5,210 • Replies: 90
No top replies

 
dlowan
 
  1  
Reply Sat 3 Jul, 2004 07:54 pm
Lol. This is a surprise?
0 Replies
 
blatham
 
  1  
Reply Sat 3 Jul, 2004 09:23 pm
No. But it is (though again, shouldn't have been) a surprise that the military has 'psychological teams' running about in jeeps with loudspeakers.

"Beloved free Iraqis...America understands your feelings. We celebrate those feelings. Close your eyes now and reach down, down, down...touch those feelings. Caress them. Own them. America wants YOU to now own your feelings. We do not wish to own them, they are yours, noble Iraqis. Your angers and hatreds and fears...in your new freedom, take ownership of that which is truly yours and yours alone. Curfew begins at sundown"
0 Replies
 
dyslexia
 
  1  
Reply Sat 3 Jul, 2004 09:27 pm
there are highly moral people that have the problem in which recognizing the truth about themselves would destroy them. they not only thrive in their mythology, they recreate the world to match.
0 Replies
 
nimh
 
  1  
Reply Sat 3 Jul, 2004 09:31 pm
To be fair, Bill did find a link with a whole lot more info (the full text of the book thats quoted in this article, in fact) - and it tells the story a little differently from how Zucchino summarises it ... link
0 Replies
 
dyslexia
 
  1  
Reply Sat 3 Jul, 2004 10:46 pm
I am somewhat reminded of the raising of the flag at Iwo Jima, a great symbolic image that had to be re-staged after the photographer showed on the scene and the subsquent death of Ira Hayes (the "hero" of Iwo Jima) in the gutter of Phoenix Arizona years later, forgotten and only surviving as the image cast in bronze, I seem to feel that the lowering of the statue be it by Iraqi's in celebration or the US troops, it served as a symbol to those that needed it and provided justification as in "we bring you freedom" or "we now have freedom." Symbols are just that, symbols, that do not contain the freedom they imply.
0 Replies
 
cicerone imposter
 
  1  
Reply Sat 3 Jul, 2004 10:52 pm
Symbols, however, are powerful tools to be used for good or bad.
0 Replies
 
Diane
 
  1  
Reply Sat 3 Jul, 2004 11:58 pm
And they help to keep people from thinking too much.
0 Replies
 
OCCOM BILL
 
  1  
Reply Sun 4 Jul, 2004 12:54 am
Click on the link below and scroll down until you see the big bold heading:
Toppling the Statue?-Army PSYOP Supports I MEF.

You will see that David Zucchino a total liar. Dude should be fired for such a deliberate misrepresentation. Btw Edgar, it would be a simple thing to change your misleading title. Idea
0 Replies
 
dlowan
 
  1  
Reply Sun 4 Jul, 2004 02:29 am
That site will not load for me, Bill.

Perhaps you can explain or copy?
0 Replies
 
OCCOM BILL
 
  1  
Reply Sun 4 Jul, 2004 07:40 am
dlowan wrote:
That site will not load for me, Bill.

Perhaps you can explain or copy?
Somehow the site shuts down my cut and paste feature completely while it is open. I just checked the link and it still works for me, and apparently it worked for nimh. Anyway, I did manually type these two quotes for my response on the other thread.

OCCOM BILL wrote:
This is a good example of how to twist a story. I remember this incident, and will forever actually; because when I saw that cheering crowd working on that statue it brought tears to my eyes. Naturally, some leftwing idiot has to try to spoil the image. Not this time. Here's what the book actually said:

Quote:
"The people had already tied a noose around the neck of the statue with some rope. They were trying to just tug on it and bring it down and were hitting it with sledgehammers; it was clearly getting crazy in the square. We were no longer in crowd control, as there was just no controlling this crowd at this time. We decided to just ride along with the crowd, and we started just kind of celebrating with the Iraqi people."


The Marines pulled it down with a chain, not a rope. You can read the actual story instead of this hyper-partisan crap (that only includes a small, misleading portion of the story) by clicking here. Like I said; the Iraqi's were already hard at work when the Marines got involved.

Looks like a good book btw. Not quite the message you guys want to believe though. Here, I'll quote some more of it from before the toppling:

Quote:
"Crowds of Iraqi citizens started coming out and cheering the American convoy. We started to do some PSYOP broadcasts about bringing about a free Iraq, but knowing that we were to continue some clearing operations; we were telling them to stay away from our military vehicles for their own safety. We eventually dismounted from our vehicle and continued to inform the civilians to stay back from the military vehicles. The Iraqi civilians were very receptive to us, and [we] continued to engage them with our interpreter."


Again, you can read the truth by clicking here.


My eyes were glued to the TV watching this unfold live. The Iraqi's were indeed dancing in the street, and the Soldiers appeared somewhat shocked at how happy these people were to be rid of Hussein. I bet it was a good 30 minutes of coverage between the time that they started filming the Iraqis wailing away with sledgehammers, shoes and whatever they could find... and the time the US Military got decided to help. At the same time they were just swamping the soldiers, apparently with thankyou's. Iraqi's were climbing all over our military equipment as if it were they were posing for pictures after a victorious football game. At first the soldiers tried to keep them back, but soon it became obvious that these people were gathered to celebrate Saddam's overthrow and were showering the soldiers in love, not hate. It brought tears to my eyes, Deb, to see these people celebrate with reckless abandon for the first time in their lives. It was one of those moments that just couldn't have gone any better. This liar, David Zucchino, took what was probably the most beautiful moment of the war and spoiled it with his straight lies.

Okay, back to the book.
PSYOP was there basically to announce our intentions as we moved through the city for the first time clearing out any resistance. The book says we were just amazed at the near utter lack of resistance this team encountered. Once there, they were caught up in celebration. It made it clear that the Iraqi's had been working on that statue before the US Military got involved. The only decision PSYOP may have made was to help the people accomplish bringing down the statue. And it may have been a PSYOP officer that ordered the overzealous American who had draped an American Flag over the head of the statue with an Iraqi flag. This would have been corrected anyway. Everyone there as well as the reporters and those of us glued to our TVs knew that it was a mistake to put our flag there. I assure you that it was an honest mistake and as soon as it was corrected the Iraqis resumed celebration with reckless abandon. For this jerk to have claimed this was staged is an outrageous lie that is not supported by anything in the book he sources (boy I'd like to pop him in the mouth for trying to spread hate out of a beautiful piece of history Evil or Very Mad ).

At this same time I remember the reporters explaining that some of the seemingly pro-Saddam cheering that was going on was at odds with the behavior of the clearly overjoyed people. It seems that chanting good things about Saddam was the only way they knew how to publicly celebrate, as it was they only way they had ever been allowed to celebrate in their entire lives. I assure you; our PSYOP people could never engineer anything this beautiful.

I sure wish there was some footage available of the 30 minutes or so before and after the toppling of that statue. I'd push it 20 times as hard as the audio file referred to in my sig line. Whether you approve of the war or not, you can at least be happy for these people. They were truly overjoyed.
0 Replies
 
nimh
 
  1  
Reply Sun 4 Jul, 2004 11:02 am
OCCOM BILL wrote:
dlowan wrote:
That site will not load for me, Bill.

Perhaps you can explain or copy?

Somehow the site shuts down my cut and paste feature completely while it is open. I just checked the link and it still works for me, and apparently it worked for nimh.

Yeh, works for me. Its huge, tho, must be dozens of print pages. No way its something to integrally copy into here.

Not possible anyway. Cant copy/paste (or print, for that matter), it seems. Or open the source text. Nifty bit of copyright protection there ;-)
0 Replies
 
dlowan
 
  1  
Reply Sun 4 Jul, 2004 12:26 pm
It appears to be a US military site? It just sits and won't load for me.
0 Replies
 
nimh
 
  1  
Reply Sun 4 Jul, 2004 12:33 pm
Its that "Army's internal study of the war in Iraq" that the LATimes article is based on, I believe. But which according to Bill is actually grossly misrepresented in the article. Full text of it.
0 Replies
 
OCCOM BILL
 
  1  
Reply Sun 4 Jul, 2004 12:38 pm
Yep, it's military all right. Perhaps they don't trust you non-US citizen bunnies. Maybe you can get in through the front door.
Try going here:
http://onpoint.leavenworth.army.mil
and then go to chapter 6, and then scroll down to the headline:
Toppling the Statue?-Army PSYOP Supports I MEF.
0 Replies
 
OCCOM BILL
 
  1  
Reply Sun 4 Jul, 2004 12:42 pm
If that don't work, let me know and I'll type it out manually.
0 Replies
 
OCCOM BILL
 
  1  
Reply Sun 4 Jul, 2004 01:32 pm
Okay, here you go:

Quote:
Toppling the Statue?-Army PSYOP Supports I MEF

We woke up that morning [of 9 April] in the Iraqi Special Forces training compound on the outskirts of southern Baghdad. Attached to 3rd Battalion, 4th Marine Regiment (of I MEF), who were conducting a clearing operation on the southern approach to Baghdad, [we were] moving with their TAC at the time. We were kept in a centralized location while moving so that we could be flexed to where we might be needed. We were not sure what we were going to hit, but we were expecting a lot of resistance. The infantry unit was to be clearing door to door, while we would be broadcasting civilian noninterference messages and occasional surrender appeals when pockets of enemy forces were located. The infantry unit started its operation but was encountering no resistance at all. After a few hours of going door to door, kicking doors and entering, looking for enemy concentrations and weapons caches but finding none, they modified their plan and formed up into a column and started a general movement toward Al-Firdos (paradise) Square in [eastern] Baghdad, where the Palestine Hotel and statue [of Saddam Hussein] were located. The entire movement went a lot faster than anyone had anticipated….

Crowds of Iraqi citizens started coming out and cheering the American convoy. We started to do some PSYOP broadcasts about bringing about a free Iraq, but knowing that we were to continue some clearing operations; we were telling them to stay away from our military vehicles for their own safety. We eventually dismounted from our vehicle and continued to inform the civilians to stay back from the military vehicles. The Iraqi civilians were very receptive to us, and [we] continued to engage them with our interpreter.

As we approached the street leading into the Al-Firdos Square, we could tell that there was a very large crowd of civilians starting to form up. It looked like the infantry unit up there could use some support, so we moved our [tactical PSYOP team] TPT vehicle forward and started to run around seeing what they needed us to do to facilitate their mission…. There was a large media circus at this location (I guess the Palestine Hotel was a media center at the time), almost as many reporters as there were Iraqis, as the hotel wsa right adjacent to the Al-Firdos Square.

The Marine Corps colonel in the area saw the Saddam statue as a target of opportunity and decided that the statue must come down. Since we were right there, we chimed in with some loudspeaker support to let the Iraqis know what it was we were attempting to do. The reporters were completely surrounding the vehicle, and we started having to ask the reporters to move out of the way, but they would not move. We were getting frustrated, but we were also laughing about it. We dismounted the vehicle again and just started pushing the formed up into a perimeter around the square, with the statue in the middle.

An M88 recovery vehicle approached the statue and continued to drive up the steps right next to the statue in an attempt to bring it down. The people had already tied a noose around the neck of the statue with some rope. They were trying to just tug on it and bring it down and were hitting it sledge sledgehammers; it was clearly getting crazy in the square. We were no longer in crowd control, as there was just no controlling this crowd at this time. We decided to just ride along with the crowd, and we started just kind of celebrating with the Iraqi people. We actually had to have our interpreter record an ad-hoc broadcast message, informing the Iraqi people that if they did not stand back from the statue, American forces would not bring the statue down. We were afraid that some civilians would get hut if they were too close or in the wrong spot.

All of this activity was going on within just a few blocks of where other marines were battling with snipers in a building across from the Palestine Hotel. The local Iraqi people just did not care for their well being at this point; they just wanted to see the statue come down… We looked over and now there was an American flag draped over the face of the statue. God bless them, but we were thinking form PSYOP School that this was just bad news. We didn't want to look like an occupation force, and some of the Iraqis were saying, ?'No, we want an Iraqi flag!' So I said ?'No problem, somebody get me an Iraqi flag.' I am not sure where it came from, but one of the Iraqis brought us the old Iraqi flag without the writing on it (added by Saddam). We got that as fast as we could and started running that up to the statue. At this time, the marines had put a chain from the boom of the recovery vehicle around the neck of the statue, and they just rand the [Iraqi] flag up the statue. It was real quick thinking of Staff Sergeant

Plesich's part to get that Iraqi flag up there quick. But by the time the Iraqi flag got put on the statue, there had already been a lot of photos taken with the marine covering the statue with the American flag.


(a photo was added here, Bill)
Figure 187. Photos of toppling the Saddam statue

Somehow along the way, somebody had gotten the idea to put a bunch of Iraqi kids onto the wrecker that was to pull the statue down. While the wrecker was pulling the statue down, there were Iraqi children crawling all over it. Finally they brought the statue down, but we expected this big statue to come crashing down, to shatter of whatever, but it just slowly bent over and slid off the mounting pipes. Once the statue was on the ground, it was attacked by Iraqis with the sledgehammers and broken apart. The head of the statue was dragged through the streets, with people hitting the face with their shoes and spitting on it. After the statue was down, we started to receive a lot of intelligence on where Ba'ath Party personnel were staying and just generally got a lot of real good intelligence for use in later direct-action missions. All this information was developed with and through the human exploitation teams, which had assigned interpreters.
0 Replies
 
Craven de Kere
 
  1  
Reply Sun 4 Jul, 2004 02:00 pm
dlowan wrote:
That site will not load for me, Bill.

Perhaps you can explain or copy?


If you use IE it should work, it won't display in Opera.

The entire page's source is encrypted so the size is very large.

It doesn't say anything to negate the title of this thread BTW, just portrays the psychological operations and stage management in a better light.
0 Replies
 
OCCOM BILL
 
  1  
Reply Sun 4 Jul, 2004 02:15 pm
Craven de Kere wrote:
dlowan wrote:
That site will not load for me, Bill.

Perhaps you can explain or copy?


If you use IE it should work, it won't display in Opera.

The entire page's source is encrypted so the size is very large.

Shocked Does that mean I didn't have to type that out by hand? Typing sucks!

Craven de Kere wrote:
It doesn't say anything to negate the title of this thread BTW, just portrays the psychological operations and stage management in a better light.
That is BS Craven. The book makes it clear the Iraqis were working on that statue before PSYOP showed up. The news coverage I watched was covering the story for a good while before PSYOP showed up. The title implies that it was a PSYOP plan for propaganda purposes, which couldn't be further from the truth. The article is a deliberate chop job to obscure the truth. Your assertion to the contrary is painting you in a hyper-partisan light. Idea

Btw, how did that page suspend my cut and paste in other programs?
0 Replies
 
Craven de Kere
 
  1  
Reply Sun 4 Jul, 2004 02:42 pm
OCCOM BILL wrote:

That is BS Craven. The book makes it clear the Iraqis were working on that statue before PSYOP showed up.


False. And you just typed it up so you should know better. They had a rope around it before they brought the chain but the statue was targeted by US military PSYOPS and they told the Iraqis about taking it down.

Here, from the text you just typed:

Quote:
The Marine Corps colonel in the area saw the Saddam statue as a target of opportunity and decided that the statue must come down. Since we were right there, we chimed in with some loudspeaker support to let the Iraqis know what it was we were attempting to do.


Quote:
The news coverage I watched was covering the story for a good while before PSYOP showed up.


Bull. Bill, quit making stuff up, this type of this is tantamount to a declaration that you do not really know what happened but know what you really would like to think happened.

Quote:
The title implies that it was a PSYOP plan for propaganda purposes, which couldn't be further from the truth.


False, that is exactly the truth. PSYOP's job is propaganda and this was a PSYOP operation in which they did their job well.

Quote:
The article is a deliberate chop job to obscure the truth. Your assertion to the contrary is painting you in a hyper-partisan light. Idea


Nonsense Bill. I don't care if PSYOPs does this, that's their job and they do it well.

You are just tying to salvage all the meaning you read into it, and that's cool because PSYOPs is not mutually incompatible with it. That PSYOPs managed this does not mean that the few hundred (probably less than 200) were not genuinely happy.

Some Iraqis really were there and happy about it. The PSYOPs made it out to be more. This was a well managed PSYOPs operation and you should not need to try to deny this.

Here are pics and clips and such since you wanted some for your signature.

Here are some wide angle shots that PSYOPs did not prefer:

http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/images/SQ1.gif

http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/images/SQ2.gif

http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/images/SQ3.gif

Here is a clip, since you said you wanted one (sorry that the Iraqis seem bored here, they get exited later when PSYOPs drag it around the street and film it.

http://68.1.17.8/informationclearinghouse3/ustroopsstatue.wmv

BBC pissed people off by this sequence that shows some wide angles and some photos that are not nice closes:'

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/in_depth/photo_gallery/2933629.stm


Quote:

Btw, how did that page suspend my cut and paste in other programs?


Javascript
0 Replies
 
 

Related Topics

Obama '08? - Discussion by sozobe
Let's get rid of the Electoral College - Discussion by Robert Gentel
McCain's VP: - Discussion by Cycloptichorn
The 2008 Democrat Convention - Discussion by Lash
McCain is blowing his election chances. - Discussion by McGentrix
Snowdon is a dummy - Discussion by cicerone imposter
Food Stamp Turkeys - Discussion by H2O MAN
TEA PARTY TO AMERICA: NOW WHAT?! - Discussion by farmerman
 
  1. Forums
  2. » Army Stage managed Fall Hussein Statue
Copyright © 2026 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 0.03 seconds on 03/07/2026 at 08:34:53