Foxfyre wrote:Hmm interesting.
And you think the 'conservative parodies' making it look like reverse psychology are incorrect? How can you be so sure?
I know they inserted text into the quotes, some range to really silly stuff.
As to whether or not it is reverse psychology I actually think it might have been and have said as much on A2K at least once.
But I know that many of the conservative sites have rewritten the quotes. As to how I know it is because I have the quotes commited to memory (as I will do with any story or quote I find memorable) and the bastardidations do not match.
Another way to tell is when only one site uses certain verbiage out of all the other ones. Then of course some are obvious. I will show you one at the end.
Quote:Seems to me knowing that they are despised and held in suspicion by the American people, it is reasonable that they wouldn't endorse a candidate they wished to be elected.
Yeah, but I won't keep trying to devine their intent as I place little importance on their statements. If they were going for reverse psychology that too can backfire and we are in that riddle loop of "he knows I will lie, he knows I know he knows I will lie".
Their Kerry comments sound like they have some sincerity what with the sleeper blasphemy but that could of course just be clever. So of course are the bastardidations of the texts that I will link to below.
Either way, the only leaning I have expressed on A2K is the one you are inclined to.
Quote:Or conversely, if you don't buy that argument, what do you think they actually see in Kerry that they would consider more dangerous to their cause?
Personally I think it was a lot of hot air and don't read much into it.
As promised here is one such example of a corruption of the statements trying to spin it for Bush:
http://blamebush.typepad.com/blamebush/2004/03/al_qaeda_endors.html
Quote:"more foolish than the AWOL Bush, who deals with matters by force rather than with wisdom."
They inserted "AWOL" in an attempt to fabricate guilt by association for liberals.
Quote:"Americans must NOT vote for Kerry," the message continued. "Kerry will kill our nation while it sleeps because he and the Democrats have the cunning to embellish blasphemy and present it to the Arab and Muslim nation as civilization.
The first sentence and the netizen capitalization for emphasis is not real.
Quote:The last thing we terrorists want is a Vietnam war hero like Kerry, who will bring peace and prosperity to the whole world, and turn the American people into complacent sheep with affordable health care and good jobs. We prefer terror and violence - and because of this we desire Dumbya to be elected - or should we say: we prefer him to STEAL the election again."
This needs no comment, it is clearly American partisans speaking and can easily be verified as not being part of the real text.
Quote:The letter, crudely written on recycled paper in green crayon, also addressed the 200 million jobs and 750,000 American lives that have been lost on Bush's watch, before concluding with a stunning postscript:
The message was not delivered in a letter.
Quote:"Let us clarify: The American people must not think we say we prefer Bush so they vote for Kerry just to spite us. We really do like the Shrub, who despite squandering a budget surplus and racking up record deficits, looks good in a flight suit and gives us more excuses to attack and kill you. John Kerry, however, is just too smart for us terrorists, and all the allies Bush alienated will rally behind the esteemed senator from Massachussetts. Do NOT vote for Kerry! And do NOT send money to moveon.org, either.
Allah Ackbar, sayonara, and all that good stuff - the Terrorists."
If it wasn't an obvious fake before, it should be now.
Only one sentence of all of that was a true part of the original without modification:
Quote:Kerry will kill our nation while it sleeps because he and the Democrats have the cunning to embellish blasphemy and present it to the Arab and Muslim nation as civilization
Only one other sentence contained a recognizable fragment of the true text.
Quote:"more foolish than the AWOL Bush, who deals with matters by force rather than with wisdom."
Remove the "AWOL" and it is the true text.
The rest is fake.