@Helloandgoodbye,
Quote:It does seem A big portion of it does boil down to interpretation of things.
Take for example Jehovah’s Witness, who conclude that Jesus is a created being from their interpretations of the evidence in front of them. They claim there is no evidence of The teaching that he is an eternal, uncreated being😳
Yes, as in your example. It all depends on how you interpret words like 'begotten' and 'created'. For me, the proper interpretation is the one that fits all the scriptures as a whole. If the whole story is not coherent, it can not be believed
and understood. I'd like to get your take on this.
What does it mean when it says Jesus is the "only begotten Son of God"? Do you believe that means that God placed himself in Mary's womb as a fertilized egg and emerged as an infant child? That conflicts with many other scriptures. As you pointed out, he was before the world began. So Jesus had to have been begotten before the world/universe/time/etc. began. When Jesus asked Peter "who do you say I am" and Peter answered "Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God", why didn't Jesus say, "No, I am God, in the flesh".
But really, it boils down to the Trinity. I don't have a religion to tell me there is one and I don't see it in the Bible. And to accept that dogma as truth you have to believe that God has a split consciousness or persona. How could he both know and not know the day of Jesus' return? How could I trust such a God who is so uncertain of his own knowledge? If Jesus IS God, he certainly would have said so in a straight forward way and not left it to a bunch of clerics to tell us 325 years later. If God does not reveal it to me directly or I don't see any sign of it in the Bible, I just don't see any reason to accept it.
The usual argument for the Trinity is that if you don't accept it, you are denying the divinity of Jesus. My answer is - How is being the Only Begotten Son of God, begotten before the universe began, given all his Father's authority on Earth, and to be seated at the right hand of God after his return, how the hell does that make him anything less than divine?
And how does one sit down at one's own right anyway? Dogma makes such a contradictory mess of things.
The JW's have got a lot of beliefs that are way off base as far as I can tell, but I agree with them on the Trinity.