@Ashley99,
Ashley99 wrote:
I don't know! It caught me off guard and I wasn't thinking rationally :/
Actually, I think you were thinking very rationally.
I agree with jcboy that you can just tell him that you didn't feel you knew him well enough at the time, that you like to be careful when talking to people online.
Think about it, this person was/is a complete stranger. How long exactly have you been talking to this guy online? You may still be at the point where you might not be wise to divulge such information. I'd continue to use a pseudonym until I was quite sure of the situation. Absolutley nothing wrong with that, and if he gets upset about it....well then I'd be thinking he wasn't the guy for me.
Back in the day, when I was dating, I never gave a guy my home address up front, and would meet him for dates. That way, I had control over my coming and going. In addition, I kept a PO box for specific purposes, and if I didn't feel sure about something, would give that address for mailing purposes.
This one guy asked me my address, and I gave him my PO box, he seemed a little surprised, but just took the information. I volunteered to him that a single woman had to be careful, and he thought for a moment, and agreed. A couple of days later I received a lovely romantic card from him.
I guess it all worked out well, because I've been married to him for 20 years.