@chrisbeeson,
So let me get this straight :
- you knew the younger wanted to play games...but you liked her
- she tells you she doesn't want anything serious / doesn't want a boyfriend
-everyone tells you that she likes to play games
- you want a stable relationship
- so you choose the aggressive one (what the???...didn't you say 'stable')...what does that tell you about your judgement of the dramatic one?
...no mention in there about your feelings for the aggressive one
- so you date the aggressive one and keep it quiet. Kelly finds out and creates drama. You 'send her away' because you don't want drama.
- After several months, the aggressive one cheats on you, and the dramatic one that hates the aggressive one comforts you...
- the dramatic one becomes your best friend (you don't go two days without seeing her), and you're interested and you tell her so, despite the fact you don't want drama, despite the fact that others say she causes drama, despite the fact that she has told you that she doesn't want a boyfriend.
At the end of all that you somehow find out she likes you, but won't talk to you.