Joining of sentences

He took a bite of the cake. He threw the cake away.

In joining the sentences, which of the following sentences is correct?

1. He took a bite and threw the cake away.

2. He took a bite of the cake and threw it away.

The second sentence is better. In the first sentence 'He took a bite and threw the cake away' this should strictly be interpreted as 'He took a bite the cake and threw the cake away' which is nonsense, but obviously no one will interpret this way, so it is maybe a small mistake.

The second sentence 'He took a bite of the cake and threw it away' is fine because 'it' means 'the cake' so the sentence means 'He took a bite of the cake and threw the cake away'.

But a better way to join the sentences would be 'He took a bite of the cake then threw it away.

Quote:

The second sentence is better. In the first sentence 'He took a bite and threw the cake away' this should strictly be interpreted as 'He took a bite the cake and threw the cake away' which is nonsense, but obviously no one will interpret this way, so it is maybe a small mistake.

How could other possibilities be nonsense, Quincy? It's certainly conceivable that a chef, angered by a student's attempts at baking a cake, chucked the whole cake.

Quote:

The second sentence 'He took a bite of the cake and threw it away' is fine because 'it' means 'the cake' so the sentence means 'He took a bite of the cake and threw the cake away'.

Don't you think this is an assumption too large?

He took a bite and threw it away.

In the sentence above, does this mean the bite or the whole cake?

Quote:

But a better way to join the sentences would be 'He took a bite of the cake then threw it away.

These types of sentences are commonly expressed in speech and it often makes little difference even if the listener[s] never know whether "it" was the bite or the whole cake.

To make it perfectly clear, the speaker could/might eschew any pronoun use and spell it out.

I'm sorry, I don't understand. Please explain this further. It is nonsense to say 'He took a bite the cake...'.

In 'He took a bite and threw it away' 'it' means 'bite', so he threw the bite away. I said 'He took a bite of the cake and threw it away' is fine because 'it' means 'the cake', the difference between your sentence and mine is clear to me.

I'm not sure what point you are trying to make.

He took a bite of the cake. He threw the cake away.

In joining the sentences, which of the following sentences is correct?

1. He took a bite and threw the cake away.

2. He took a bite of the cake and threw it away.

Which dismisses much of what you have written.