@JTT,
JTT, the judge was removed from the case in 1978, because of inappropriate conduct, like talking about the case with reporters, and bragging about how he would put Polanski away for a long time. I'm not defending the judge.
They want to open an investigation into the plea deal arrangement that was made with Polanski, and the conduct of the judge, since a lot of mishandling of the case might have occurred. They should do this, they should have done it a long time ago. There was a good deal of backroom maneuvering with this case, and 33 years later they may not be able to piece it all together. The judge died in 1993, so they can't question him. It is relevant to the issue of why Polanski fled the country.
I want Polanski to get a fair deal. If the judge in the case was about to renege on a plea agreement, and throw Polanski into jail for his own reasons, that would have been wrong. They should try to determine what happened.
I'm not really interested in seeing Polanski go to jail now. I'm not sure that he would have done additional jail time in 1977 under that plea agreement. He did 42 days in jail as part of a psychiatric evaluation, and I don't think the prosecutor was asking for more. The snafu was coming from the judge. I think they should offer him the original plea again and give him time served. Why they haven't been able to work this out in 33 years I can't fathom. But I think they should work it out, have Polanski return to California, enter his guilty plea, receive his sentence of time served, and conclude the legal case against him in an appropriate manner.
The courts seem to have enormous problems dealing with high profile celebrity cases. They do turn into media circuses. The spotlight seems to affect the judges and everyone else involved. Polanski's celebrity and influence was always a factor in this case and it's still a factor. He's never gotten quite the same treatment as the ordinary person accused of the same crimes would have received. If he ever does return to a California courtroom, the media will be swinging from the rooftops and clogging the roads. It will be a spectacle.
But I still think they should wrap the case up legally rather than leave it hanging any longer. The recent extradition fiasco with Switzerland was ridiculous. The longer the case drags on legally unresolved the more absurd it gets. It is time for legal closure--in a California courtroom, with Polanski present.