Reply
Mon 23 Apr, 2007 01:49 pm
Dear readers:
It?s very disheartening that I, a young African-American male in the year 2007, feel the necessity to write a letter discussing America?s continuous deprivation of basic rights for Black America. Let me be clear, I comprehend that America has made a significant amount of change since the late 1960?s, but that?s not enough, and if you think that comment sounds a bit ungrateful, then you tell me why I should be grateful. Should I be grateful that my country, since Lincoln freed the slaves, has failed to produce or enforce legislation that guarantees all Americans, including Blacks, equal rights under a fragile Constitution? Better yet, should I be grateful that my race is still negotiating for birth-given rights with a country that claims to be the land of the free, or should I simply be grateful that I am an American? Well, I not grateful.
When America gives me a reason to be grateful, you will know. My freedom, my equality are not things that I should have to bargain or beg for each day, and personally, I think the United States? goal is not to see Black America completely free, but rather to simply feed us enough to keep us quiet. My race is starving in a land of opportunity because we are spoon fed by the white man?s hand. Damn it, I can feed my self. I don?t need appeasement, but what I do need is my freedom and my equality without limitations. Can anyone tell me why we need civil rights laws to enforce rights established by the Constitution in a democracy? The answer is obvious, we don?t live in a democracy we live in hypocrisy, and history has proven this statement to be true.
With that said, how can we expect Iraq to understand democracy when the truth, after two hundred plus years of democracy, is that the United States is still failing Black America? It?s simple, HYPOCRISY! To say one thing and do another, now that?s the American way. The problem with the American way is that the white male has been the face and voice of America since the formation of this country, and history teaches us that you either live that way or fall victim that way. There are always exceptions, and there will always be people who succeed above expectation, but can we really accept the fact that the white male imagines that around the world he represents America when in actuality we are much more than that. Why does the majority of the world hate me simply because I am American when my own country hates me because I am black? It is a no win situation simply because the world does not recognize our struggle for equality because they see all Americans as arrogant white males set on world domination.
This letter is not a personal attack on the white race or the white male. It?s my reflection of history in hope of coming up with a plan that will set my people completely free. I?m neither Moses nor a black savior, but you can consider me a freedom fighter. I will not watch my people fall by the waste side simply because of our race. The Jim Crow?s days are over, and somebody needs to inform America. Well here I am Willie James Harvey, and believe me, I will never sugar coat anything. If your **** stinks I will tell you. AMERICAN YOUR **** STINKS! I?m not a reverend like King or claim to be a prophet, but I do consider myself a man of great faith who will always speak my mind.
Some people will say this is nothing but anti-American propaganda, but I am an American, and most importantly, a believer in free speech. You can criticize or debate what I say, but history is my proof. The Constitution gives me the right to make known my frustrations with this country. I wish that the topics that I will discuss in this letter weren?t true, but they are and I have moral and personal reasons to not just turn the other cheek. Anyway, I have never been a cheek turner, but I have been known to turn cheeks. I refuse to just sit, wait, and hope that one-day America will change. I shouldn?t have to expect my equality tomorrow or the day after, I want my equality today. Let?s get the ball rolling America, we can and we must.
There is no compromising when you are dealing with mandatory rights. To quote an infamous president, George W. Bush (43rd),?you are either with us or against? for freedom or against freedom, but America I ask you: What will you stand for? How in the hell can Americans be fighting in Iraq to establish democracy when the real fight is in the United States of America? I can only come up with one: America cares more about Iraqis than they do about the welfare of Black America. Saddam Hussein is dead and gone, yet Jim Crow is still walking and kicking. Where is the logic in that America? How long do you really expect Black America to be this country doormat? Enough is enough, and I can guarantee you that if America chooses to continue to walk over Black America that a racial war will be on our horizon.
Now that may sound crazy, but the reality is that the majority of my race is frustrated with this country, and you should never under-estimate a group of people who desires to be free. I will now end this brilliant better-put forewarning letter with a quote from James Baldwin?s book The Fire Next Time:
?When I was very young, and was dealing with my buddies in those wine- and urine-stained hallways, something in me wondered, What will happen to all that beauty? For black people, though I am aware that some of us, black and white, do not know it yet, are very beautiful. And when I sat at Elijah?s table and watched the baby, the women, and the men, and we talked about God?s or Allah?s vengeance, I wondered, when that vengeance was achieved, What will happen to all that beauty then? I could also see that intransigence and ignorance of the white world might make that vengeance inevitable- a vengeance that does not really depend on, and cannot really be executed by, any person or organization, and that cannot be prevented by any police force or army: historical vengeance, a cosmic vengeance, based on the law that we recognize when we say, ?Whatever goes up must come down.? And here we are, at the center of the arc, trapped in the gaudiest, most valuable, and most improbable water wheel the world has ever seen. Everything now, we must assume, is in our hands; we have no right to assume otherwise. If we-and now I mean the relatively conscious whites and the relatively conscious blacks, who must, like lovers, insist on, or create, the consciousness of the others-do not falter in our duty now, we may be able, handful that we are, to end the racial nightmare, and achieve our country, and change the history of the world. If we do not now dare everything, the fulfillment of that prophecy, re-created from the Bible in song by a slave, is upon us: God gave Noah the rainbow sign, No more water, the fire next time!?
I will always preach peace, but I will never exclude violence as a reasonable option because my mind?s capacity is too vast to limit my expectation of a completely free and functioning democracy in America. I dream like King but fight like Ali. Created in God?s image, I am a king among kings, a rose in a concrete jungle. I need water and this is my last warning: I am officially frustrated America. Until the next letter, be good, be safe, and be peaceful with love and faith. ONE
Sincerely,
Willie James Harvey
a.k.a.
The God Father of the South
Author of ?I Am Not a Slave, So I Write?:
A Collection of Thought-Provoking Poems
@wjharve,
thanks for joining, please go to the introduction section and introduce yourself
In short:
Equality won't be reached when congress passes laws protecting the rights of one group of Americans, it will be reached when all Americans understand that the current laws apply to every color and creed. That cannot be accomplished by the American politican, it can only be accomplished by the American family.
Your beef is not unique, until the invention of Native American Casino's African Americans have had it WAY better then our Native countrymen had ever had it.
When this country was started only free, land owning, men could vote. By that standard I would have been oppressed too. It will never be perfect, but so long as it continues to get better what more is there to do but try?
There is also the component of the Victim's mindset. Believing your at a disadvantage is twice as bad as actually being disadvantaged by another...
@wjharve,
Lots of talk and rambling in there, but nothing else.
@wjharve,
I understand that every race in some form or fashion has been discriminated against and honestly only a fool would say that Native America at any point in history had it worst off then Black America. I understand their struggles and support their effort also to achive equality, but don't you think Black America deserve to be treated better in this country. After all my ancenstors put a lot of sweat and blood into this country only to see America help all other races out. Hate is Hate so lets not agrue who got screwed the worst by America because the list is long and see if we can come up with a peaceful solution. I refer to the Black American struggle because that is what I am but let me be clear I don't want to live in a perfect America, I want to live in equality. I will not settle for better, because what has that ever got Black America nothing but more hard times. I don't believe that I am at a disadvantage, I know it and actually that is what motivate me to do better simply because I know that I have to work that much harder than a white man to achieve the same goal.
@wjharve,
wjharve;13295 wrote:only a fool would say that Native America at any point in history had it worst off then Black America.
Then consider every unbiased expert (and Chris Rock) a fool. Black America may have been enslaved, and that's horrible. But Native American suffered Genocide, by definition much worse then slavery.
Blacks have made uncountable contributions to America's society. But no race has contributed more then another.
Anglo Saxons- forged the government
Africans- forged agricultural prosperity
Asians- Built our railroads
Irish& Italians- Populated our factories and therefore the industrial revolution
I could go on
no one color of man has contributed any more then another. There are many groups of people who face discrimination on some level in this country. But fighting for the rights of one particular sect alone, and not all of America, is in and of itself a form of Racism.
One of the real pieces missing from American society is the will to move on. Consider the terrible things done by Germans to the Jewsih just 50 years ago. Yet still it *could* be argued that in 50 years Germany has done more to heal it's wounds then America has since 1863
@wjharve,
wjharve;13274 wrote:My race is starving in a land of opportunity because we are spoon fed by the white man?s hand. Damn it, I can feed my self. I don?t need appeasement, but what I do need is my freedom and my equality without limitations.
You have the freedom to go and receive free education, and get a job just like the rest of us. I don't see what you have to complain about.
@wjharve,
Can you imagine how many Africans died in travel to the new world piled on top of each other aboard a massive slave ship. By definition ain't that's the same as genocide. Correct me if I'm wrong. Don't be a fool
Silverchild79;13301 wrote:Then consider every unbiased expert (and Chris Rock) a fool. Black America may have been enslaved, and that's horrible. But Native American suffered Genocide, by definition much worse then slavery.1863
because Chris Rock gets paid to be a fool.
@wjharve,
if you want to split hairs they weren't actually trying to kill them, but slavers, the "tight pack" slavers in particular were barbarians. Where as Native Americans were hunted down and killed, Cholera Blankets, the trail of tears, these things are just as bad, and in some cases worse then slavery.
But again we're splitting hairs, all that ish is bad. But I've never owned a slave, and if you've ever done a day of free work in your life you volunteered. I'm a white collar Irish American who's grandparents were hungry farmers and who's parents were drafted into Vietnam. If you want something to be no more it must be put behind you.
I would ask you this, are you for equality, or are you for the advancement of the Black Populous of America?
@B A N A N A S,
B A N A N A S;13308 wrote:You have the freedom to go and receive free education, and get a job just like the rest of us. I don't see what you have to complain about.
I don't complain, my letter is really informing you not me whining. You might want to read the whole letter before posting a quote.
@Silverchild79,
Silverchild79;13372 wrote:
I would ask you this, are you for equality, or are you for the advancement of the Black Populous of America?
Honestly, I want and deserve them both. Correct me if I am wrong. Thank you
@wjharve,
wjharve;13369 wrote:Can you imagine how many Africans died in travel to the new world piled on top of each other aboard a massive slave ship. By definition ain't that's the same as genocide. Correct me if I'm wrong. Don't be a fool
because Chris Rock gets paid to be a fool.
If you believe that it is you who is the fool. The Spanish massacred The Inca empire into extinction, still feel worse? You said to correct you if your were wrong, well, Your Wrong.
@wjharve,
wjharve;13374 wrote:I don't complain, my letter is really informing you not me whining. You might want to read the whole letter before posting a quote.
What makes you think that is the first time we have read something like that?
@wjharve,
wjharve;13377 wrote:Honestly, I want and deserve them both. Correct me if I am wrong. Thank you
Quote:Honestly, I want and deserve them both.
No you don't. For some reason you think this is owed to you? That to me means you think you or your people are victims? I know if i ask you directly if you are a victim your probable answer will be no but yet you will stick to this mental ideal you hold to be true that sociaty owes you something? Who is holding you down? The man or your thought of the man? You said again to correct you so your welcome.
@wjharve,
wjharve;13377 wrote:Honestly, I want and deserve them both. Correct me if I am wrong. Thank you
All I will say is that advocating the advancement of a singular color/creed of people will never be good for equality, regardless of contex
@Drnaline,
Drnaline;13381 wrote:No you don't. For some reason you think this is owed to you? That to me means you think you or your people are victims? I know if i ask you directly if you are a victim your probable answer will be no but yet you will stick to this mental ideal you hold to be true that sociaty owes you something? Who is holding you down? The man or your thought of the man? You said again to correct you so your welcome.
To correct me I have to be wrong and I'm not. History is history and we are victim just like anybody else that been and still is getting screwed by the United States. I can't changed that and likewise I will not let that be an excuse. All I am trying to do is point out the fact that democracy is still running over Black America and really you can't argue differently, so why do.
@Drnaline,
Drnaline;13380 wrote:What makes you think that is the first time we have read something like that?
Did I say that? No, but it's the first time you read my letter. I want equality for all not just Blacks, now quote that.
@Silverchild79,
Silverchild79;13423 wrote:All I will say is that advocating the advancement of a singular color/creed of people will never be good for equality, regardless of contex
Neither is racial profiling, so what is your point.
@wjharve,
African-Americans that want to better themselves usually do so . Many have achieved the American Dream , but many more seem content to live on welfare and cry racism rather than take advantage of the freedoms and rights and priveledges of America .
Take the word to the brothers and sisters - get them up and working , not playing victim .
@wjharve,
wjharve;13424 wrote:To correct me I have to be wrong and I'm not. History is history and we are victim just like anybody else that been and still is getting screwed by the United States. I can't changed that and likewise I will not let that be an excuse. All I am trying to do is point out the fact that democracy is still running over Black America and really you can't argue differently, so why do.
Quote:To correct me I have to be wrong and I'm not.
Shall we take a poll?
Quote:History is history and we are victim just like anybody else that been and still is getting screwed by the United States.
So why don't you leave? It is because you think something is owed to you? Do i owe you something, i am a citizen? Did i or anyone else in this forum perpetrate this on the black people of the US? So why do we have to make restitution for the percieved indisgression?
Quote:I can't changed that and likewise I will not let that be an excuse.
You can't or won't change? And if you ask me, you have already used is as an excuse a few times?
Quote:All I am trying to do is point out the fact that democracy is still running over Black America and really you can't argue differently, so why do
What your pointing out is not a fact it's an opinion. It's an opression that you allow to hold you down. Coming from a minority myself i have pracitcal experiece that says your wrong. I am who i am because of me, you are not yourself because you feel sociaty have done you and your people an injustice. So when you said you deserved it, that is why i said you didn't.
I have a friend that is an immigrant from South Africa. He is an upscale businessman who came to this country thirty years ago with nothing. He is a first generation immigrant. I asked him what he thought of black oppression in the US. He gave me a bewildered look and after pausing said he had no idea what i was talking about. I think that strainge as he is black and according to you therefore oppressed. Yet he had no idea? How do you explain that? What is the difference between him and you? Besides a feeling? In anycase, i think i can argue different so i will do so.
@wjharve,
wjharve;13425 wrote:Did I say that? No, but it's the first time you read my letter. I want equality for all not just Blacks, now quote that.
I didn't say you said that?
Quote:I want equality for all not just Blacks, now quote that
Funny, from what i've heard. Your pretty much just talking about black up to this point. In your first post you mention "black" ten times. In the whole thread fifteen times. I think we know who your biased for?