@Reconstructo,
Reconstructo;113636 wrote:Well, let's just drop the word "God" for this next question. What I mean,I suppose, is this: where does it all come from? Why the universe in the firt place? I'm not saying that this is valid question but that it is a strange and fascinating question. Why something rather than nothing?
For the most part questions are a pleasure for me, as I am quite the happy person, despite all the trouble on earth.
I have spent the past few days off and on trying to answer or at least give some insight into my understanding of your question 'Why something rather than nothing? I cant without God and as you asked for this to be a less than faithful answer i find it even harder to answer than i ever thought.
And even with God i dont come much closer to anything that i see as plausible or descriptive even, it could be to do with purpose but the question in my mind is soemthing that precedes purpose something some excuse for there being something to excuse, so dont think i haven't spent time in the company of this most fundamental even genesis of a question.
What came to me yesterday was, 'What is ...is', but i dont think this fulfils the fullness of what you asked.
So tonight i was given 'What would a moth be without its flame?'
Because i think that the question asks why there is reason over the example of a reason it is really hard to answer,
so i thank you profoundly for a question we all ask ourselves but are rarely asked by another, nice to know we all dont have all the answers or even just that one,
This is an important question, 'Why something rather than nothing?'
If you could give me source material of where and why you found this question it might help me in answering it for myself first and then give you a responce.
Do you have an answer, or as i suspect is it a question that can only ever be asked without a finish.
Thank you again.