The reason i described Hunt as "superior" is because not only is there a high quality in terms of artistic quality, but Mr. Hunt also gets the technical details of how sailing vessels were rigged and handled at sea correct. Here's a perfect example of what i mean:
This shows
HMS Surprise with her "stunsails" (studding sails) rigged out. (Look at the long, narrow strips of canvas at the side of the sails at the top of the first and second masts, those are the studding sails.) If you look carefully you can see that the way the yards are braced, the wind is coming from very far aft of the port quarter. If you were standing on deck facing forward, you would feel the wind on the left side of your neck, but it wouldn't even brush your face. It would not be directly behind you, but just to the left of directly behind you. Almost all marine artists when showing a ship with stuns'ls rigged shows them to port
and starboard of all the sails on both the main mast and the fore mast, which is just stupid. If you were running before the wind, or with a quartering wind far aft, setting stuns'ls on your main mast on both sides would effectively rob the sails on the foremast of their wind, defeating the purpose of putting out your stuns'ls in the first place. Additionally, stuns'ls were almost never rigged on the courses (the lowest sails of the main and fore masts).
This painting is delightfully accurate. The stuns'ls are rigged on the starboard side of the tops'l (top sail) and the togarns'l (top gallant sail), and on the port side of the fore tops'l and the fore togarns'l. This means that they are being most effectively used. The implication is that there is a good steady wind, but not of great force. It appears that they have just let fall the main course (lowest sail on the middle mast), suggesting that although the wind is steady and seems reliable, it is not so strong that it would threaten to carry away any sails or rigging. Note also that the royals (the fourth sail from the bottom) are set. The entire picture says to me that they have a steady but not especially strong breeze coming over the taffrail on the port side, very far aft, but not so far aft that they are actually running before the wind. By setting royals (the fourth sail up from the deck) it implies that they are attempting to get the most from a steady wind which is not terribly strong. The stuns'ls set on the starboard side of the tops'l and the togarns'l don't rob any of the sails of the fore mast of their wind, and the stuns'ls set on the port side of the fore tops'l and fore togarns'l don't rob the jibs and forestays'l of any wind. Note also that they don't have any stays'ls (stay sails) set other than the fore stays'l, which would also otherwise rob sails forward of the stays'ls of their wind. They are setting as much canvas as possible in the most efficient manner to get the greatest benefit from the available wind.
This is a much higher quality of technical representation than you can necessarily expect from all marine artists.