@PeanutButterJelly,
So I'm seventeen and my boyfriend is ninteen.
They have some really cool gifts to give at this store called BROOKSTONE. If you havent heard of it, its great, you can go look at their store online or probaly find one near you.
I went there and got him a fogless shaving mirror for his bathroom, because he has to shave everday. He really liked it. I know that may seem funny because were so young that i would give a present like that but its great. Of course i gave him a lot of other stuff, but that presesnt he uses everyday and likes a lot.
Valentines day is coming up and I'm thinking about going there again. They have these Tempurpedic Mattress Slippers that I'm thinking about getting.
Hopefully that helps, but go check out that place, your bound to find something wonderful for your man !