@Builder,
Builder wrote:You need proof. This is an adult debate site, right?
In theory, but I still recall that you engaged in unprovoked name-calling in our earlier encounter some months ago. And now you seem to be jumping back and forth between name-calling and serious discussion.
On the other hand, you've stumbled across a subject where I am particularly well equipped to address the facts, and am eager to do so.
Builder wrote:I offered you proof that both Nagasaki and Hiroshima were civilian targets.
Hiroshima was Japan's largest military town, and was Japan's primary military port for deploying soldiers overseas. Its military districts were packed with tens of thousands of Japanese soldiers (giving it the highest soldier/civilian ratio of any Japanese city). Also, Hiroshima Castle held the military headquarters in charge of repelling any invasion in the southern half of Japan (which at the moment of the bombing was still where we were planning to come ashore when we invaded).
The primary target of the second A-bomb was Kokura Arsenal, a massive (4100' x 2000') arms-production complex that was supplying the Japanese military with all sorts of weapons. The secondary target was Niigata (another big military port, sort of a lesser version of Hiroshima). The tertiary target was the Mitsubishi Shipyards, a
massive warship construction facility near Nagasaki.
Due to technical and weather difficulties, the bomb ended up being dropped on Urakami, an industrial zone north of Nagasaki. There it destroyed both the Mitsubishi Steel Works and the Mitsubishi Torpedo Works.
Before Japan attacked us, Pearl Harbor had been regarded as immune to air-dropped torpedoes because the water was so shallow that the torpedoes would hit the ocean floor and embed themselves in the mud. This was the only harbor in the world (outside Japan) that had such a natural defense against air-dropped torpedoes. In order to attack us, Japan had to find a way to modify their torpedoes so that they would defeat these unique defenses. The aforementioned Mitsubishi Torpedo Works was the place that produced these modifications.
(The damage to the torpedo factory was quite satisfactory.
)
Builder wrote:Where is your evidence?
Hiroshima:
"Hiroshima was a city of considerable military importance. It contained the 2nd Army Headquarters, which commanded the defense of all of southern Japan. The city was a communications center, a storage point, and an assembly area for troops. To quote a Japanese report, "Probably more than a thousand times since the beginning of the war did the Hiroshima citizens see off with cries of 'Banzai' the troops leaving from the harbor."
http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/mp06.asp
"Out of 140,000 deaths, about 20,000 were considered to be those of the military service men."
http://web.archive.org/web/20050525025545/www.hiroshima-cdas.or.jp/HICARE/ab2e.html
"Hiroshima before the war was the seventh largest city in Japan, with a population of over 340,000, and was the principal administrative and commercial center of the southwestern part of the country. As the headquarters of the Second Army and of the Chugoku Regional Army, it was one of the most important military command stations in Japan, the site of one of the largest military supply depots, and the foremost military shipping point for both troops and supplies. Its shipping activities had virtually ceased by the time of the attack, however, because of sinkings and the mining of the Inland Sea."
http://www.trumanlibrary.org/whistlestop/study_collections/bomb/large/documents/index.php?pagenumber=8&documentid=7-1&documentdate=1946-06-30&studycollectionid=abomb
"There were 43,000 soldiers based in Hiroshima, and Nagasaki was an industrial city that had turned out the torpedoes used at Pearl Harbor. Its shipyards had built some of Japan's biggest warships."
http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/trinity/articles/closer1.html
Nagasaki:
"The bomb exploded high over the industrial valley of Nagasaki, almost midway between the Mitsubishi Steel and Arms Works, in the south, and the Mitsubishi-Urakami Ordnance Works (Torpedo Works), in the north, the two principal targets of the city."
http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/mp07.asp
"In Nagasaki, only the Mitsubishi Dockyards among the major industries was remote enough from the explosion to escape serious damage. The other three Mitsubishi firms, which were responsible together with the dockyards for over 90 percent of the industrial output of the city, were seriously damaged. The Arms Plant and the Steel Works were in the main area of damage."
http://www.trumanlibrary.org/whistlestop/study_collections/bomb/large/documents/index.php?pagenumber=15&documentid=7-1&documentdate=1946-06-30&studycollectionid=abomb